Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


What Would a Livable Wage Actually Look Like?

  +Follow December 26, 2013 9:20AM
Tickers Mentioned:

On July 15 McDonalds Corporation (MCD) released a sample budget for employees outlining how to better manage their finances on $24,720 a year. Here it is:

The chart was widely mocked on several fronts. For one, in the “income” section, it assumed an employee would have an undefined “second job” that brought in 46.3 percent of their earnings. Second, the chart budgeted impossibly low figures for things like health insurance – at $20 a month (the average American pays $215 a month in premiums) – and food and gas, which weren’t budgeted for at all.

Assuming the employee make minimum wage, at a rate of $7.25 an hour (the wage McDonald’s starts employees at), he or she would need to work 72 hours a week to hit that benchmark.

With their “Practical Money Skills” handbook, McDonalds inadvertently showcased that they– like many of their compatriots in the service industry – do not pay a wage capable of sustaining an adult. And as over 88 percent of minimum wage earners are over 20,   

Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA) introduced the Fair Wage Minimum Act of 2013 to raise the federal minimum wage to $10.10 an hour by July 2015. An aide of his explained it this way: “Let’s say we had indexed minimum wage to inflation in 1968. The minimum wage would then be at $10.56 today. The fact we’re at $7.25 minimum wage shows it has lost almost a third of its real value.”

The $10.10 hourly wage wouldn’t even keep pace with the minimum wage’s peak value in 1968. Even getting to that benchmark is considered untenable. But a higher minimum wage would certainly raise those numbers quite a bit.  

So what would the McDonalds budget look like on $10.10 an hour?

A Remade Budget

Let’s assume that, since we can’t be sure what inflation will be like going forward, this $10.10 wage applies to 2013.

At $10.10 an hour, and according to the chart McDonalds supplies, the employee would be making $37,814 a year, which is certainly a comfortable wage. That’s three timers over the federal poverty line for a family of one, and fifty percent over the poverty line for a family of four.

But of course, that’s assuming the worker has two jobs and is clocking 72 hours a week. Quite a bit above the 40 hour work week that formed the backbone of the labor reforms instituted following the employee abuses of the Industrial Revolution.

A Remade, Remade Budget

Let’s go ahead and assume that the worker is only going to work 40 hours a week at one job. At $10.10 an hour, that’s $21,000 a year, before taxes. That’s under the poverty line for a family of four, but still good enough to keep an earner almost two times more than a one person household.

It’s still not up to the $24,720 a year the hypothetical McDonalds employee would make. So someone making $10.10 would have to trim $3,720 a year from their budget, or $310 a month.

McDonald’s plan calls for the employee to save $100 a month. Cutting that leaves $210 a month left. Since there’s no budget for gas, let’s go ahead and remove the car payment of $150 a month and assume the employee walks everywhere. From this, it’s not too much a stretch to assume this employee could lose $60 a month off the $750 a month for discretionary spending.

Of course, this leaves a person without a car, money for transportation, and less than $25 a day in discretionary spending.

As noted earlier, the original chart lacks some expenses many people find essential. What would it look like then if the spending chart reflected someone who more accurately resembled an average American? That is, spent $25 a day on discretionary items, paid the national average in health insurance, had a car, and had to pay to both maintain it and put gas in it?

A Remade, Remade, Remade Budget

The McDonalds chart doesn’t account for food and gas in its essential expenditures. According to the USDA’s May 2013 food plan, a “thrifty” male between the ages of 19-50 can maintain a nutritious diet at $182.20 a month, if they’re in a family of four. If they live alone, it’s 20 percent more, or $218.24, with all meals prepared at home. A “liberal” food plan according to the USDA is double that, but let’s go ahead and say this person is watching their money closely. They’re on a budget, after all.  It should be noted that women spend around 20 percent less than men on food, so let’s go ahead and use a figure of $180.

For cars, let’s talk averages. On July 30 the average price of gas was $3.62 a gallon. The average American adult male driver clocks around 18,000 miles a year (female drivers, around a third of that.) And the average mid-sized American car gets 24.6 miles to the gallon. That’s 666 gallons of gas a year. Let’s split the difference on genders and say the employee drives 14,000 miles a year. That’s $2,060 a year on gas, or about $171 a month.

Then there’s maintenance. AAA reports this at 4.47 cents a mile, or $560 a year. Add in the cent a mile in tire replacement costs, and you’re at exactly $700 a year, or $58 a month in car upkeep.

Comparing what “average Americans” pay for health insurance plans can be an apples to oranges scenario, so let’s just go with Washington Post writer’s analysis of plans in his hometown of Irvine, California, where he found the average plan was around $114. Even McDonald’s own cheapest plan offered to employees costs $728.74 a year, and only covers up to $2,000 in coverage. Their “Cadillac” plan, which caps benefits at $10,000, is $1,680 a year – or around $140 a month. Of course, Obamacare will affect these rates as well,and in the case of young healthy people will probably make that rate even higher.

For a Grand Total of….

Adding together gas, food, and the company’s own premium insurance plan – which is still less than stellar –and you can tack $549 a month in expenditures, which raises McDonald’s sample budget to $2,609 a month.

So what would a person working merely 40 hours a week have to make to cover that?

$15.05 an hour. Double the current minimum wage, and fifty percent more than what the Senate's liberal wing is proposing.

Even if you took out all car related expenses, and budgeted zero for transportation, and gave them the most basic catastrophic health plan, it’s still expenditures of $2,300 a month, requiring $13.20 an hour.

Critics argue that minimum wage jobs aren't intended to be kept forever. But the numbers show minimum wage isn't even half of what a single person needs to survive.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Liked What You Read? Join Equities.com and Connect With Your Favorite Financial Experts FOR FREE! Members of Equities.com gain access to our leading financial news and content, active social investment community, proprietary research tools including the 2014 Small-Cap Stars, E.V.A. reports and more.

Results for MCD
Timm Anderson
21 Oct 14 04:13:16
Zero Filter
21 Oct 14 04:11:07
@BrianSozzi I've been saying this desperately needed for months. TWO ELEPHANTS: Management & Food $MCD
Rosner Stocks
21 Oct 14 04:06:43
$EWL 52Wk High Click Here: http://t.co/smTW0AF5ha Also See: $EPI $DD $MCD $BABA ~
21 Oct 14 04:05:37
Futures point to fourth day of gains; Apple rallies http://t.co/lXtiRIkCxa $AAPL $KO $VZ $MCD $TRV $TXN $NDX $S500 $DJI $COMP $IBM
Investors Hangout
21 Oct 14 03:43:49
$EWJ Short Sales Click Here: http://t.co/LpqFr1MCJl Also See: $TVIX $EWL $UST $MCD ~
Jasper Lawler
21 Oct 14 03:40:49
US markets look for higher open ahead of McDonalds, Coca-Cola earnings | CMC Markets UK $MCD $KO http://t.co/Vdn4yNZ6fJ
Brian Sozzi
21 Oct 14 03:18:41
40 Photos that Show Creative Reasons Why #McDonalds is Failing http://t.co/f8V81ic8nn $MCD
Brian Sozzi
21 Oct 14 03:15:41
It feels as if big management changes are coming for #McDonald's, not before year end, but soon after. $MCD
Howard Penney
21 Oct 14 03:13:33
Chipotle co-CEO rips into fast-food chains for "short-sighted" mistakes $MCD $WEN $YUM $JACK http://t.co/TiSkfwUyMi
21 Oct 14 03:01:01
Weekly Dow #Stocks Trend $UNH $BA $V $PG $KO $NKE $GE $MMM $UTX $AXP $T $XOM $MCD $VZ $CVX $DD $CAT $DIS $HD @ http://t.co/TvzJfd0RGT
♥ @MyOrgone ♥
21 Oct 14 02:48:14
Scrap $MCD!!! Earn 100% per year with our 'Top 10 Hedge Fund' Artificial Intelligence - http://t.co/JnYV7VSLtQ $QQQ @CNBC
21 Oct 14 02:30:33
$MCD Earnings out BMO EPS Estimate 1.38
Leilani Pips
21 Oct 14 02:24:50
21 Oct 14 02:23:02
Published $MCD estimate on Estimize: 50% of Mac Donalds' revenues come from outside of the U.S. Hen... http://t.co/yPCcuEQ5De
Investors Hangout
21 Oct 14 02:13:51
$ELTP Ideas Click Here: http://t.co/nIxTtvKUrx Also See: $FLY.V $SLB $MCD $FLY.V ~
Investors Hangout
21 Oct 14 02:01:22
$EIRL Market Cap Click Here: http://t.co/AwalUNXerg Also See: $FNMA $SVFC $ISNS $MCD ~
21 Oct 14 01:58:32
It's Apple versus China for market focus. $AAPL, $GS, $MCD. http://t.co/ogfBqWSf5z http://t.co/kuMU6yKX6D
21 Oct 14 01:57:50
Apple smashes expectations for sales, profits. $AAPL, $SPX, $MCD. http://t.co/wlMPiPBd42 http://t.co/asGDEoCrmP
21 Oct 14 01:55:41
McDonald's, Amazon, and Philip Morris Investors Should Pay Attention To a Strengthening Dollar. $MCD, $AMZN, $PM. http://t.co/dn77dQgL8R
21 Oct 14 01:51:13
5 Reasons No Fast Food Chain Can Touch Chipotle. $CMG, $MCD, $NE. http://t.co/tNWuxzUvAr
21 Oct 14 01:51:03
McDonald's Botches “MythBusters” Social Media Blitz. $MCD, $FB, $CMG. http://t.co/HS3bGpoAJV
Business News
21 Oct 14 01:25:07
RT @TheStreet: Spite the volatility! All you need is technical analysis. Let's start with trades for Coke and McDonald's http://t.co/k5acZy…
21 Oct 14 01:15:16
Spite the volatility! All you need is technical analysis. Let's start with trades for Coke and McDonald's http://t.co/k5acZyMJDw $MCD $KO
♥ @MyOrgone ♥
21 Oct 14 00:47:32
Sell $MCD! Make 100% a year using our 'Top 10 Hedge Fund' Artificial Intelligence - http://t.co/x7MDlPJXnp @CNBC $QQQ
Investors Hangout
20 Oct 14 23:34:38
$CTIX Tick Click Here: Also See: $MCD $XLB $TEO $CVX ~
Ayaki Kay Smith
20 Oct 14 23:19:32
Apple Smashes Q4 Views On Hot iPhone 6, Mac Sales http://t.co/jPCauZPh37 #IBDNews @IBDinvestors $AAPL $MCD $WAG $WFMさんから
Storm Trading
20 Oct 14 23:09:09
RT @AG_Capital_: $AAPL came in better than exp, oil leads commodities higher after beat on CH: Q4 GDP. BIL (Q1 update), $KO $VZ $MCD http:/…
Glen Korstrom
20 Oct 14 23:03:49
McDonalds reports earnings tomorrow a.m. Will be interesting to see update on Russia crackdown, implications of high US$ #fastfood $MCD
20 Oct 14 22:49:47
RT @jimwisdom: Apple Smashes Q4 Views On Hot iPhone 6, Mac Sales http://t.co/Ft3Sj3flHI #IBDNews via @IBDinvestors $AAPL $MCD $WAG $WFM
Jim Wisdom
20 Oct 14 22:30:07
Apple Smashes Q4 Views On Hot iPhone 6, Mac Sales http://t.co/Ft3Sj3flHI #IBDNews via @IBDinvestors $AAPL $MCD $WAG $WFM
AG Capital
20 Oct 14 22:12:04
$AAPL came in better than exp, oil leads commodities higher after beat on CH: Q4 GDP. BIL (Q1 update), $KO $VZ $MCD http://t.co/40soPXXxjR
20 Oct 14 21:38:48
Russia's Crackdown On McDonald's Intensifies $MCD http://t.co/KycKSrGuXP
20 Oct 14 20:46:15
RT @m_cof: McDonald’s has missed revenue targets for the past 5 quarters. What to look for Tuesday http://t.co/TCQVpRRcKa $MCD http://t.co/…
Patrick Seitz
20 Oct 14 20:36:41
Apple Smashes Q4 Views On Hot iPhone 6, Mac Sales. http://t.co/enX3bDmaGL $AAPL $MCD $WAG $WFM
20 Oct 14 20:34:42
Russia Investigates More Than 200 McDonald's (Newsweek) http://t.co/xgMfnqDaTl $MCD
Colin Macleod
20 Oct 14 20:34:10
October 21 2014 Earnings to watch before the bell http://t.co/C2iHCYhmEw $RF $KO $VZ $UTX $MCD $HOG $PNR $GPK $TRV & More
20 Oct 14 20:28:03
McDonalds is having a burger crisis. http://t.co/22aHjXsuoS http://t.co/AcltlJzo1N $MCD
John Michael
20 Oct 14 20:11:11
RT @daily_finance: Suffering franchisees of McDonald's pin hopes on Monopoly, McRibs http://t.co/JHKZHkmksp $MCD
20 Oct 14 20:10:10
Suffering franchisees of McDonald's pin hopes on Monopoly, McRibs http://t.co/JHKZHkmksp $MCD
20 Oct 14 19:51:22
$MCD whisper number 1.38, more at http://t.co/P9IHXIR7m2 #MCD
20 Oct 14 19:43:19
HBO (and on YouTube) The wonderfully funny and wise John Oliver. Taking on $MCD, the Midd... #LastWeekTonight #tvtag http://t.co/yjYI6QyE4N
20 Oct 14 19:37:04
$KO $MCD $YHOO report earnings tomorrow $MCD should be interesting. reports showing very weak on numbers
Es tu Dinero
20 Oct 14 19:26:45
RT @TheStreet: Spite the volatility! All you need is technical analysis. Let's start with trades for Coke and McDonald's http://t.co/utPUrL…
Nicolas Litvinoff
20 Oct 14 19:20:58
RT @TheStreet: Spite the volatility! All you need is technical analysis. Let's start with trades for Coke and McDonald's http://t.co/utPUrL…
20 Oct 14 19:15:15
Spite the volatility! All you need is technical analysis. Let's start with trades for Coke and McDonald's http://t.co/utPUrLrt30 $MCD $KO
Ryan Morse, CMT CFP®
20 Oct 14 19:11:49
$LMT with a big report for us in the morning, other div plays reporting in the am are $KO $KMB $MCD
20 Oct 14 18:56:05
#FastMoneyEspresso FINAL TRADES: Dan Nathan—> sell $IBM Tim Seymour —> buy $MCD Karen Finerman —> buy $FINL Guy Adami —> buy $FB
20 Oct 14 18:55:32
RT @WrigleyTom: Some #earnings $IBM $AAPL $CMG $MCD $CREE $VMW $YHOO $BIIB $NXPI $NOW $YELP $DNKN $UA $AMZN $DECK $MSFT $P $UPS http://…
Jeff Gauvin
20 Oct 14 18:50:17
RT @HamzeiAnalytics: #Comrade #Putin's Latest Target: More Than 200 Russian McDonald's http://t.co/lZU6tbPECG #MCD $MCD
20 Oct 14 18:47:02
Would be funny if $MCD up 10% and $CMG down 10% tomorrow #saidnohedgefundever @zerohedge @BarbarianCap
  +Follow December 26, 2013 9:20AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.