Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


Clive Palmer and the Sino Iron Project: the Disaster that Keeps on Giving

By  +Follow September 19, 2013 2:52AM
Tickers Mentioned:

When reading about Australian multi-millionaire Clive Palmer, one could perhaps be forgiven for receiving the impression that the man is an Australian version of Donald Trump.

Indeed, the mining tycoon-cum-politician is often described, by himself and others, as a successful businessman who has made a fortune from a number of shrewd moves in Australian hard commodities, particularly through his Mineralogy Pty Ltd.’s holdings in coal, nickel, and iron-ore. For what it is worth, Forbes Magazine estimates the 59-year old’s fortune at just shy of a billion dollars.

But Palmer’s very public and frequently bizarre outspokenness, especially when it comes to personal beef with various rivals, is also a significant aspect of the mythology that surrounds the man.

It doesn’t help matters that his performance during these high-profile incidents often takes on a distinctly unsavory quality. For instance, only two weeks ago, Palmer threatened to sue Rupert Murdoch, whose newspaper The Australian published a piece questioning just about every aspect of the man’s claims about his own success. The article’s author unequivocally characterized Palmer’s most recent foray into Australian politics during the current election cycle as nothing less than a threat to the country’s democratic process.

In a riposte that would likely garner scant attention had it originated from Donald Trump himself, Palmer took to Australia’s morning talk-show circuit the next day to blast Murdoch, referring to him as “this foreigner who tries to dictate what we do.” And then, as if to make sure that everyone was clear about the deliberately xenophobic nature of this remark, he took it an improbable step further by claiming that Murdoch divorced his wife after discovering that she was spying for the Chinese. The scenario reads like a strange photonegative of Trump’s dalliance with birther theology during last year’s presidential election.

Another incident from recent memory involves last year’s accusation that the well-known environmentalist organization Greenpeace was actually on the payroll of the Central Intelligence Agency. According to Palmer, who perhaps fittingly has made his fortune in part off of this most pollutant of energy sources, the most feared group of spooks in the world was keenly interested in destroying Australia’s coal-mining sector (Greenpeace called the accusation “ludicrous,” while the CIA for its part issued the standard denial).

But this synopsis of the unsavory actions of one man in the public eye becomes relatively insignificant when considering Palmer’s oft-vaunted business acumen. The story here stretches a little further back, to 2006, when he sold the mineral rights to a magnetite iron ore site to Hong Kong’s Citic Pacific Ltd. for $391 million and royalties.

Citic Pacific is actually the Hong Kong-based segment of China’s largest state-owned steel-centric investment vehicle. The prospective iron-ore mine, located in the country’s rugged northern Outback region, is called the Sino Iron Project. China is the world’s largest consumer of iron ore, and Sino Iron is its largest foreign magnetite iron-ore mining and production venture.

Iron-ore production has boomed in recent years, primarily as a response to astronomical Chinese economic growth that has lifted untold thousands out of poverty, and been a mainstay of the global economy since the turn of the millennium. The construction boom in the world’s most populous nation has vacuumed up large amounts of natural resources, particularly hard commodities such as copper and iron-ore, and has been one of the main reasons that the world’s biggest mining companies, such as Vale SA (VALE) , Rio Tinto (RIO) , and BHP Billiton (BHP) have recalibrated their production strategies to focus on these two metals in particular.

Thus, the 2006 deal between Citic Pacific and Palmer can be seen in the context of China’s desire to become more independent in terms of natural resources; currently, the country relies on the major miners for its commodities as those companies are on China for their revenues and profits. The only problem, however, is that the Sino Iron project has yet to produce one ounce, much less one ton, of magnetite iron ore.

Sino Iron, in actuality, has been an unmitigated disaster for the Chinese government in terms of its ostensible goals in entering the deal, as well as from the perspective of public relations. The project has been hampered by all manner of complications. Repair work for construction of the mine’s first two production lines should have been complete months ago, though it is now estimated that the necessary fixes will take at least another two years, at an estimated additional cost of some $1 billion.

But this extra billion brings the total spent on Sino Iron to some $8 billion. Unfortunately for the Chinese Government, it would be impossible, from the standpoint of public perception, to have abandoned the mine at any point after having shelled out $2.5 billion, so the project continues. Citic Pacific has at least taken the step of taking Palmer to court in Australia over the royalties agreement they signed with him.

The bad news doesn't end there for China however. After several years druring which the mining industry has directed its efforts towards the iron-ore rush, we are now in a situation where the metal is expected to hit record surplus by next year, which many banks, including Deutsche Bank (DB) and Goldman Sachs (GS) , have predicted will force prices lower for the foreseeable future. If an when Sino Iron does start producing metal, it is doubtful the project will ever really be able to pay for itself.


***correction: the original version of this article stated that Citic Pacific bought the mineral rights to Sino Iron for $2.5 billion. In fact, that figure was much lower, at $391 million. The article has been amended to reflect the correct figure***

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Signup for our daily newsletter and get our best articles emailed right to you!

Results for vale
Candance Schulz
30 Aug 14 04:01:31
$VALE Why Vale S.A. ( http://t.co/ADWeFulP76
Alpha Maven Alerts
29 Aug 14 21:32:11
$VALE, Active, Yesterday, SD +3.11, #NYSE #BasicMaterials
Market News Desk
29 Aug 14 15:53:18
$VALE: Why the demerger of non-core assets makes sense for BHP http://t.co/JrHHMgcDSW http://t.co/RvUlE4OFmt
Wall Street News
29 Aug 14 14:53:07
$VALE: BHP’s FY14 results were broadly in-line with market expectations http://t.co/lIuJphOCeZ http://t.co/09JA9T9pt2
29 Aug 14 14:31:17
Top Shorted Stocks 08/29/14 1. $XLF 82.29% 2. $AMX 78.08% 3. $CNHI 72.69% 4. $ATVI 69.73% 5. $SPY 69.19% 6. $VALE 68.75% 7. $WSM 67.65%...
29 Aug 14 14:31:14
Top Shorted Stocks 08/29/14... 4. $ATVI 69.73% 5. $SPY 69.19% 6. $VALE 68.75%... http://t.co/LpChhVuLqm
29 Aug 14 14:29:53
@TweetLeni Yes, setting up as a nice contrarian play going into next year.The Whiff of deflation is keeping them contained now. Prefer $VALE
TV_Trading Ideas
29 Aug 14 12:47:46
Another opportunity in VALE here @ $13 $VALE http://t.co/p8Hhc363AY
29 Aug 14 12:47:46
$VALE chart: Another opportunity in VALE here @ $13. http://t.co/H1gqdoKMfb
29 Aug 14 12:42:12
Bought positions in $SWHC and $VALE
Stocks in News
29 Aug 14 11:53:22
$VALE: A Good Day For Peru Gold Miner Buenaventura http://t.co/4soUmJk97Y http://t.co/rIvilIT8uY
Sam DiSalvo
29 Aug 14 11:33:13
$VALE back in the dog house in short order
Karin Jeter
29 Aug 14 11:12:02
$VALE Zacks Industry Ou http://t.co/fi1rAqWFvA
Gerardo Benitez
29 Aug 14 10:46:22
RT @TweetsMillenia: #Ironore prices hit lowest since October 2009 http://t.co/yxI1FyJUow $SID, $VALE, $CLF, $RIO, $BHP. Despite very low pr…
Mark Yusko
29 Aug 14 10:25:33
RT @TweetsMillenia: #Ironore prices hit lowest since October 2009 http://t.co/yxI1FyJUow $SID, $VALE, $CLF, $RIO, $BHP. Despite very low pr…
Millenia Panama
29 Aug 14 10:07:44
#Ironore prices hit lowest since October 2009 http://t.co/yxI1FyJUow $SID, $VALE, $CLF, $RIO, $BHP. Despite very low prices avoid for now
Stock Status
29 Aug 14 10:06:58
Lunchtime Most Active #stocks $SPLK http://t.co/qaITftFdWu $VALE http://t.co/dLufGjj5Lf $INTC http://t.co/4y8N0yVSk9
Stock News Updates
29 Aug 14 09:53:21
$VALE: Mozambique’s Likely Next Leader Invites Investors to Build Roads http://t.co/vZAl6VvHlp http://t.co/G3VGHCn7zh
29 Aug 14 09:45:25
$TCEL Chart $TCEL Most recent stock chart and technical analysis. $VCIT $ERBB $PLUG $VALE $TBT $SSYS http://st http://t.co/2Igo0cc62m
David Dierking
29 Aug 14 09:38:17
Iron ore prices hit lowest since October 2009 http://t.co/Y8mhctQ5dk $SID $VALE $CLF $RIO
Leilani Salisbury
29 Aug 14 09:21:51
$VALE Zacks Industry Outloo http://t.co/j3Btxo8Tqt
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 09:18:51
DennyT: TASR Recent News $TASR $VALE $GILD $SSYS $SCTY http://t.co/Jojxf9pyda
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 09:18:48
DennyT: TASR Recent News $TASR $VALE $GILD $SSYS $SCTY http://t.co/HREPjfo2bK
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 09:15:41
jim50: $VALE Low Date=Aug-28-2014 Open=13.26 High=13.29 http://t.co/i0RkRO1HeN
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 09:15:41
jim50: $VALE Low Date=Aug-28-2014 Open=13.26 High=13.29 http://t.co/xBtuCry7ds
Harry Walkman
29 Aug 14 09:00:57
$VALE Why Are Brazilian Stocks Red Hot? – Gerdau SA (ADR) (GGB), Companhia ... http://t.co/BziD8lOuEP
Financial News
29 Aug 14 08:53:18
$VALE: Brazil Steel: No Positive Catalysts Ahead? http://t.co/7raVyP7x4u http://t.co/oboYuqNmMz
29 Aug 14 08:47:30
$VALE Low Date=Aug-28-2014 Open=13.26 High=13.29 Low=12.91 Close=13.11 Volume=48060500 http://t.co/rlWH2DL6CH
Donald van Deventer
29 Aug 14 08:29:07
RT @KamakuraCo: Vale Overseas Ltd. Bond Issue Tops "Most Active" Trade Volume Rank, August 28, 2014 $VALE http://t.co/pUtjSkODUA via @salph…
Sam DiSalvo
29 Aug 14 08:23:04
$VALE is trading as if it DOESN'T have a semi-annual 9.5% annual yield DIVIDEND PAYMENT coming up in mid October. OPPORTUNITY PEOPLE!
Sam DiSalvo
29 Aug 14 08:16:36
$VALE>13.... looks good (for now)
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 08:12:44
danrocks: $JPM On Watch $VALE $AA $UNG $BAC $IMSC http://t.co/eKafzT7Hic
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 08:12:44
danrocks: $JPM On Watch $VALE $AA $UNG $BAC $IMSC http://t.co/4o3q8JAjOc
TheStreet Alerts
29 Aug 14 08:04:23
Why Vale S.A. $VALE Stock Continues to Fall Today http://t.co/bTGLq0fnxC
Andrew Meola
29 Aug 14 08:00:41
Why Vale S.A. $VALE Stock Continues to Fall Today http://t.co/LRuTghO1FM
29 Aug 14 07:59:18
$JPM On Watch $VALE $AA $UNG $BAC $IMSC http://t.co/0aoChkWa2u
Quantpost Basic Mats
29 Aug 14 07:55:44
$VALE News Alert: http://t.co/Q5j8eezjdk Updated options view: https://t.co/EKyBrKCkZl All options views: https://t.co/OmDYbXnHv6
29 Aug 14 07:55:43
Iron ore prices hit lowest since October 2009 http://t.co/Rfad29NwPZ $SID $VALE $CLF $RIO
Sam DiSalvo
29 Aug 14 07:54:26
$VALE needs to hold 12.90 or face a spectacular flame out ..even more than the last 2 years have brought.. maybe $6 in1yr to $20 if it holds
Business News Now
29 Aug 14 07:53:22
$VALE: Notable Movers - Vale SA (ADR) (NYSE:VALE), SouFun Holdings Limited ... http://t.co/b32Krcy8op http://t.co/Q2rV4KRVCl
Dimitra DeFotis
29 Aug 14 07:50:08
A Good Day For Peru Gold Miner Buenaventura http://t.co/nrUqyaB954 via @barronsonline $HMY $GDX $VALE $MMXMY $BVN #metal #iron
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 07:44:13
DennyT: VALE Morningstar $VALE $DE $XLE $AEZS $GOOG http://t.co/EzgxnbhjVb
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 07:44:13
DennyT: VALE Morningstar $VALE $DE $XLE $AEZS $GOOG http://t.co/0BcbCmziYy
29 Aug 14 07:23:50
$VALE fell on iron ore news, usually big volume down marks a bottom but wouldn't bet on it here, wait 2-3 weeks
29 Aug 14 07:17:01
$VALE Sep Block Trade: 618 trade. ~$0.8 MM notional value.
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 07:10:59
DennyT: XLB Insider Disclosure $XLB $GD $VALE $EPI $BITA http://t.co/B50ZIYYgAW
Investors Hangout
29 Aug 14 07:10:58
DennyT: XLB Insider Disclosure $XLB $GD $VALE $EPI $BITA http://t.co/8eftYmnoqF
us stocks update
29 Aug 14 07:00:32
RT @Thought2Execute: I liked $VALE at $15 and still like it at$20. Watch this baby #runhigher going into the long weekend.
29 Aug 14 06:58:59
RT @OptionAlert: Largest open interest increases among single stock options for 8/29 include $AAPL, $TWTR, $BAC, $EBAY, and $VALE.
Stock Market Monitor
29 Aug 14 06:53:18
$VALE: Vale SA (ADR) (NYSE:VALE) Has Lower Outlook In Eye of Analyst While ... http://t.co/DPC6upHaJy http://t.co/NBGgDB2Lwg
By  +Follow September 19, 2013 2:52AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.