Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


Financial Myths: Work Smarter Not Harder — Part III

By  +Follow July 1, 2014 7:21AM
Tickers Mentioned:

value of business consultants, working harder versus working smarter, examples of working smarter, bad business advice

Much like Garrison Keillor’s Lake Wobegone Days, everyone wants to be above average, so, by definition, people work smarter if not harder. The first installment showed that this myth appeals to many but it fails to yield unvarying success.

Jumbo Shrimp, Anyone? 

Part II looked at the curious tendency toward oxymorons, an ironic word for the Work Smarter devotees. The platform concept in manufacturing generates its own incongruity – small car extravagance; fuel efficient large car feel, affordable luxury. Curiously, this apparent lack of logic may open the door to market hegemony as emerging markets cut into the apple of success.

The myth deserves a more probing exploration of the “Work Smarter” notion. Those who work smarter spur the product and business methods sovereignty of the United States. Iconic brands such as Coca Cola (KO) , Microsoft (MSFT) , Apple (AAPL) , McDonald’s (MCD) and Phillip Morris (PM) circle the globe. Business practice leadership shows itself in the growth of Masters of Business Administration (MBA) programs worldwide, including the former Soviet Union. Students see American business practices as the most practical and successful.

Despite a long record of such breakout successes, popular wisdom holds that the US economy is in a slump and that China will soon rank first. What an opportunity for the Myth Buster!

Satchel Paige’s idea that “Something might be gaining on you” is not new. In previous decades, it was widely believed that Japan would overtake the American economy through seizing ideas that are loosely considered American and making them better: cameras, televisions and automobiles, for example, Canon (CAJ) , Sony (SNE) and Panasonic (PCRFY) . Japanese firms made their mark through a single-minded dedication to quality. Even though the Iphone is thought to have changed the way people communicate, Samsung, a South Korean company, holds higher market share than Apple. So, the idea of Americans inventing a product or technique and someone else perfecting it has been in our face for decades.

A major adherent to this subset of the Work Smarter Not Harder myth is Germany, which is also grabbing American ideas and making them work. The latest target is less attractive emerging markets. Take, for example, the expansion of on-line shopping. The wizard behind the curtain is a German company, Rocket Internet GmbH, which employs 27,000 in 50 countries. While eBay (EBAY) focuses on Russia, China and Brazil – members of the well known BRIC group -- Rocket Internet uses concepts developed by Amazon (AMZN) , Groupon (GRPN) and eBay to target Latin America, Africa (especially Nigeria) and the Middle East. While the American progenitors of online shopping reap the profits of the wealthiest markets, German entrepreneurs make the concept work in the shadow of the United States and Europe, much as Japan first focused on small cars with superior quality.

Being Smarter and Working

An intriguing sidebar of this myth is those who really are smarter; how hard they work is another matter. If you have been in management for a long time, you know that some senior managers possess limited experience managing people, money or projects. They reach their positions by fitting the profile of a good manager -- they’re smart. At least they appear smarter than their colleagues.

Some years ago, the author worked for a CEO who thought he could raise $35 million based on his ability to convince others of the soundness of the project. He flopped. Only when a feasibility study was created that showed the purposes and uses of funds and how the investment would work did the financial spigots turn on. The CEO convinced himself that he wrote the feasibility study. After all, he was smarter than everyone else. It is rumored that he is now selling sand in the Sahara equipped with attractive financial projections.

This vignette reveals the power of this myth – being smart can outduel experience and hard work. Here is how it works. Think of an organization that abhors a new technology, a competitor or a new product. How can they find independent verification for their passion? Senior managers are more likely to believe a point of view if it comes from an outside consultant. Outside means independent; consultant means smart.

According to Duff McDonald’s The Firm: The Story of McKinsey and Its Secret Influence on American Business, one of the worst examples of bad advice was McKinsey & Co. advising AT&T against mobile phones. Let’s give this the myth buster review. Which company did not want to hear that mobile phones had potential? AT&T (T) , the masters of land lines and wall phones? By comparison, which organization was most certain that Fed Ex’s (FDX) overnight mail idea was ridiculous? The Post Office (USPS)? Beyond the idea that mobile phones really might have been a bad idea at that time and beyond the notion that McKinsey could couch its recommendations in a dizzying array of statistics, outside experts confirming what management thought would prove very welcome.

This smart consultant effect is true even if the manager inside the company already believes the idea and even if he or she told the consultant about the idea. Notice the distinction. Many critics cite consultants for giving bad advice. In many instances, they only delivered bad advice derived from the company.

So, some managers who listen to the consultant’s presentation are thinking they agree because they already knew what the consultant says. A few disagree but cannot say anything – after all, the advice is coming from smart, independent consultants. Underlying this sweet spot of the management consultant is the Work Smarter Not Harder myth.

Considering three installments on this intriguing myth, it has staying power. But to get the most out of it, do both: Work Smarter and Harder. The next article will examine another compelling myth.


Michael McTague, Ph.D. is Executive Vice President at Able Global Partners in New York, a private equity firm.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Signup for our daily newsletter and get our best articles emailed right to you!

Results for ko
28 Jan 15 19:22:01
Our Penny Stock Picks On $IJJP $TUNG & $QLTS Gained 117% In 3 Days! New Pick Coming: http://t.co/c7bXDM1sfp $TWO $KO $EMR
Stock Wire
28 Jan 15 17:40:50
Short Interest of The CocaCola Co Increases by 2.3% $KO http://t.co/5aZsrocsHe
Nelson W
28 Jan 15 17:29:32
I've been a $KO @cocacola shareholder for nearly 30 years, & I am sick of all the crap!: #HFCS cornsyrup in powerade, now Acesulfame! Ban it
Quantpost Cnsmr Good
28 Jan 15 16:44:08
$KO News: "My Dividend Portfolio: 2014 Year In Review $ADP $AMGN $BDX $BP $CHD …" http://t.co/pcenLDFBRb Board view: https://t.co/2HO5A2OPkR
Seeking Alpha
28 Jan 15 16:44:04
My Dividend Portfolio: 2014 Year In Review http://t.co/cQY5Gj8Qbi $ADP $AMGN $BDX $BP $CHD $CL $CLX $CVS $DIS $FHCO $GE $HSY $JNJ $KO
Sherilyn Balazs
28 Jan 15 16:04:02
$HYG $GPRO $UPRO $KO Is the Real Breakdown Coming, or is this Another Fake-out? http://t.co/1sR5IdVfrp
28 Jan 15 16:00:55
Dow #Stocks Trend $BA $MMM $HD $UTX $UNH $TRV $CSCO $WMT $V $PFE $DIS $MRK $DD $NKE $JNJ $KO $INTC $AXP $IBM $GE @ http://t.co/TvzJfdisOX
28 Jan 15 15:54:08
The "Stock Options 101" HD Video package is 100% FREE. http://t.co/STnJTqyeL6 $WFM $KO $MRK $BMGP $SPG $MNKD http://t.co/oPyrQwT1Ze
28 Jan 15 15:31:08
@jimcramer: 1 down $mcd a couple more to go $twtr $cat $ko $ups
Dividend Diplomats
28 Jan 15 15:20:07
#Stocks slid today, NEW! Expected Dividend Increases in February http://t.co/Fl86UE2RjX $ADM $BMS $KO $KMB $TROW $WMT
Rosner Stocks
28 Jan 15 15:09:05
$SVXY Short Sales Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 5:59:22 PM $KO $XIV $CSTE $GGAL http://t.co/OdHFSQbHEu
28 Jan 15 15:01:07
$KO: Coke, Nissan and Bradesco to Sponsor Rio's Olympic Torch Relay: http://t.co/87qwYLOe2f
Mark Friend
28 Jan 15 14:48:47
RT @Benzinga: Has @WarrenBuffett Lost His Touch? Not Even Close $BRK-A $BRK-B $COP $IBM $KO $WFC $XOM http://t.co/ZAo2J3YyxC http://t.co/xr…
Stock Wire
28 Jan 15 14:02:09
Coca-Cola Co. (KO) Closes 1.11% Down on the Day for January 28 $KO http://t.co/4VWTic0R39
Sherilyn Balazs
28 Jan 15 14:00:46
$HYG $GPRO $UPRO $KO Mid-day Market Update January 28th, 2015 $AAPL $PCLN $TLT $SPY http://t.co/nGKapJOqsK
Wall Street
28 Jan 15 13:44:21
http://t.co/iQWRYqnOQl....Top penny stocks, NYSE, and NASDAQ trades from the stock market today. +296% last week. $AA $KO $BSX $AVNR
Morningstar, Inc.
28 Jan 15 13:15:15
What Impact Will a Rising Dollar Have on Dividend Payers? http://t.co/qJnWYDE3d3 $PM $KO
Rosner Stocks
28 Jan 15 13:02:42
$KO Financials Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 2:59:25 PM $AVGO $SLB $FXI $TVIX http://t.co/laJC9maNSY
28 Jan 15 12:59:19
Dow #Stocks Trend $BA $HD $MMM $UTX $UNH $MRK $TRV $WMT $PFE $CSCO $DIS $V $KO $NKE $DD $INTC $JNJ $GE $CVX $T @ http://t.co/TvzJfdisOX
Langan Stocks
28 Jan 15 12:56:16
$CYTK News Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 3:03:24 PM $UGAZ $RIG $KO $OIL http://t.co/uYg9vz5X7w
Tomorrows Bluechips
28 Jan 15 12:54:37
RT @rosnerstocks: $FXCM Last Price Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 12:59:26 PM $KO $IMSC $FCX $SBUX http://t.co/2CClHjVNpv
28 Jan 15 12:43:53
RT @OptionsFlux: $KO Feb. 20, 2015 PUT 42.00 : +8.368 contracts add to OI
Food Dive
28 Jan 15 12:05:12
Coca-Cola Canada decreases sweetness, provides smaller packaging: http://t.co/xWklKRgRqU @CocaColaCo $KO
David Borough
28 Jan 15 11:54:41
When you can't grow your own business invest in others $KO $MNST $GMCR http://t.co/lFbLD5J4lT
Sherilyn Balazs
28 Jan 15 11:30:31
TRADE WELL http://t.co/o6PqlxZaOF $F $GE $T $BAC $VZ $C $AA $JPM $KO $PFE $GOOG $EBAY $FB $TWTR http://t.co/IlJJD3VTDe
Dividend Diplomats
28 Jan 15 11:15:14
Like #Stocks? and #Dividends? NEW! Expected Dividend Increases in February http://t.co/Fl86UE2RjX $ADM $BMS $KO $KMB $TROW $WMT
28 Jan 15 11:11:36
Our Penny Stock Alert On $QLTS Has Gained 34.62% In The Past 2 Days! Special Update: http://t.co/MNFk4FhSe1 $TWO $KO $EMR
Rosner Stocks
28 Jan 15 11:00:44
$FXCM Last Price Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 12:59:26 PM $KO $IMSC $FCX $SBUX http://t.co/2CClHjVNpv
Langan Stocks
28 Jan 15 10:53:42
$DIA News Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 1:03:26 PM $KO $IYT $WYNN $BAC http://t.co/4vkmBsR602
28 Jan 15 10:45:13
$KO resistance noted @ the MBB, parabolic sars in a downtrend, possible point of interest is 41.85 for possible lower gap closure
Lauren Holmes
28 Jan 15 10:30:28
$WFC $KO $IBM stocks we closely track from $BRK.B portfolio in http://t.co/VrsGMCgPOC
28 Jan 15 10:18:24
Theca-Cola’s “Hold” Rating Reiterated at Jefferies Group $KO http://t.co/Nhwkz7A8pu
IH News Desk
28 Jan 15 10:08:40
$KO Financials Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 12:11:30 PM $GS $PCLN $XLI $NEM http://t.co/DrhLtVHnTn
Altitrade Partners
28 Jan 15 10:01:58
$KO $NSRGY $PEP $DPS $MNST $CELH Our report on new Big Beverage trends has been picked up on the NASDAQ web site http://t.co/EYd12Ry9ZF
28 Jan 15 10:00:42
$IWM Recent News Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 12:07:29 PM $XLK $XLF $EWT $KO http://t.co/RY94Drccde
28 Jan 15 10:00:12
The "Stock Options 101" HD Video package is 100% FREE. http://t.co/STnJTqyeL6 $WFM $KO $MRK $BMGP $SPG $MNKD http://t.co/ostp7apBx8
Langan Stocks
28 Jan 15 09:52:09
$KO Financials Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 12:03:28 PM $TLT $DXJ $WYNN $RGLD http://t.co/up4GnfHimA
My Financial Wisdom
28 Jan 15 09:45:23
Dividend Investing http://t.co/8TGkCCzEw0 #DividendInvesting #StockMarket $AXP $GS $MCO $WMT $USB $WFC $PG $IBM $KO $XOM #Investment #money
28 Jan 15 09:35:19
@benzingajoe @LaMonicaBuzz Um. AMEN. PS: really tired of them using my likeness in image #2. #attribution people!!! ; ) $KO
28 Jan 15 09:32:51
RT @benzingajoe: Another silver cylinder of joy, please... http://t.co/x10GyodHFP $KO you feel me, @TALENTEDBLONDE or @LaMonicaBuzz ?
28 Jan 15 09:09:07
Barcelona! Take me back! $XLF $FXI $BAC $KO $EEM $TLT $EWT $COP $QQQ $VXX $XOP http://t.co/JUFJoVNc4s http://t.co/10zX2kIVYZ
IH News Desk
28 Jan 15 09:07:17
$FNMA Stock Price Updated Wednesday, January 28, 2015 11:11:26 AM $KO $FNMA $IYT $XLE http://t.co/FZFyZOfHci
Dividend Diplomats
28 Jan 15 08:58:08
NEW! Expected Dividend Increases in February http://t.co/Fl86UE2RjX $ADM $BMS $KO $KMB $TROW $WMT
28 Jan 15 08:57:01
@jimcramer are you taking #AmIDiversified on TWTR? If yes, how about $BABA, $JNJ, $KO, $KMB, $XOM. Am I diversified?
Penny Stock Secret
28 Jan 15 08:55:22
This Man Turned $100 Into Over $10,000 In Just 30 Days! Proof Here http://t.co/SVqoMlijqL .. $TWO $KO $EMR
28 Jan 15 08:51:16
Dow #Stocks Trend $UTX $MMM $PFE $UNH $MRK $HD $TRV $GE $CVX $DD $BA $CSCO $WMT $V $DIS $NKE $INTC $KO $JNJ $IBM @ http://t.co/TvzJfdisOX
28 Jan 15 08:40:20
RT @OM_giveaways: The "Stock Options 101" HD Video package is 100% FREE. http://t.co/STnJTqyeL6 $WFM $KO $MRK $BMGP $SPG $MNKD http://t.…
My Financial Wisdom
28 Jan 15 08:36:05
Dividend Investing http://t.co/OYrOKMP2yX #DividendInvesting #StockMarket $AXP $GS $MCO $WMT $USB $WFC $PG $IBM $KO $XOM #Investment #money
28 Jan 15 08:30:28
I love this trading girl! $XLF $FXI $BAC $KO $EEM $TLT $EWT $COP $QQQ $VXX $XOP http://t.co/l9JkTCL0PV http://t.co/qS1TDMhNFM
US Banking News
28 Jan 15 07:59:41
Theca-Cola Given Consensus Recommendation of “Buy” by Analysts $KO http://t.co/eJqhazlc6P
By  +Follow July 1, 2014 7:21AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.