Midwestern Banks with the Best Fundamentals

Jacob Harper |

As we’ve discussed before, investing in regional banks represent about the purest play on the economy itself. Unlike their opaque, wildly leveraged cousins in investment banking, regional banks tend to rely on good old-fashioned banking fundamentals. That is, when times are good, they can loan out more money and rake in more cash, and when times are bad, people default on loans and they can’t lend out as much.

Pretty simple really. It reasons then that if an investor is bearish on economic prospects, they should avoid betting on a bank. However, if they are bullish on the economy, investing in a regional bank can be a rather straightforward way to capitalize on that optimism.

Our Methodology

Picking out a regional bank play can be daunting. We decided, for the time being, to limit our search to a specific geographic region. In this case, we  looked only at banks in the an oft-overlooked region for investment, the Midwest.

But of course, even if one is bullish on the American (and more specifically, Midwestern) economy, one can’t just go picking stocks to throw money at willy-nilly. There has to be some criteria, after all, preferably of the fundamental variety.

To find the fundamentally strongest banks in the Midwest, we looked for regional banks that have:

1) A P/C and P/B greater than 1

It is important for finance companies to have strong book value and cash, but validation of these assets by the market is also a key factor. So, while price ratios are generally stronger when lower, a P/C (price to cash ratio) or P/B (price to book ratio) of 1 should be a minimum “floor” for investing. This does not mean, though, that high P/C or P/B ratios are a good sign, simply that a minimum level of market acknowledgement is a necessity.

2) An operating margin greater than 25%

Operating margin shows how efficiently a company is operating is business after a good is sold. Gross profit-operating costs. The operating margin is more appropriate for banks because the costs associated with operating are much more significant for a bank than the cogs.

3) An ROI greater than 25%

Return on Investment, or ROI, shows how well a company is using its invested capital. Since banks are essentially made up of all invested capital, this is a very important statistic.

Our Findings

Out of all of the Midwestern banks trading on the market, we found a total of ten that possess all three of these attributes and thus can be considered to be the fundamentally strongest regional bank stocks in America. They are:

First Business Financial Services (FBIZ)

Price: $47.45

P/E: 13.60

Performance YTD: +26.17 percent

Community Bank Shares of Indiana (CBIN)

Price: $22.94

P/E: 10.38

Performance YTD: +18.86 percent

Mutualfirst Financial Inc. ($MSFS)

Price: $17.61

P/E: 17.61

Performance YTD: +11.36 percent

Independent Bank Corporation (IBCP)

Price: $12.92

P/E: 3.94

Performance YTD: +7.67 percent

Ohio Valley Banc Corp (OVBC)

Price: $22.72

P/E: 11.09

Performance YTD: +1.70 percent

First Financial Bancorp (FFBC)

Price: $17.10

P/E: 20.60

Performance YTD: -1.04 percent

Mercantile Bank Corp (MBWM)

Price: $20.81

P/E: 10.62

Performance YTD: -2.98 percent

German American Bancorp (GABC)

Price: $27.39

P/E: 13.83

Performance YTD: -3.01 percent

Firstbank Corporation (FBMI)

Price: $18.55

P/E: 12.79

Performance YTD: -3.79 percent

Taylor Capital Group (TAYC)  

Price: $22.84

P/E: 15.03

Performance YTD: -14.07 percent

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions. To read our full disclosure, please go to: http://www.equities.com/disclaimer


Symbol Name Price Change % Volume
AJGH AJ Greentech Holdings Ltd 14.00 0.00 0.00 0
FBIZ First Business Financial Services Inc. 22.97 0.31 1.37 1,783
FFBC First Financial Bancorp. 21.48 0.00 0.00 53,488
GABC German American Bancorp Inc. 38.09 -0.09 -0.24 1,897
IBCP Independent Bank Corporation 16.59 -0.16 -0.96 3,762
MBWM Mercantile Bank Corporation 27.69 -0.17 -0.61 5,538
OVBC Ohio Valley Banc Corp. 23.03 0.00 0.00 0


Emerging Growth

Kiwa Bio-Tech Products Group Corp

Kiwa Bio-Tech Products Group Corp develops, manufactures, distributes and markets, cost-effective and environmentally safe bio-technological products for agriculture in China.

Private Markets


Lyft matches drivers using their own personal vehicles with passengers who request rides through the smartphone app, and the passengers pay automatically through the app. When using Lyft, passengers have…


Wealthfront is an automated investment service that serves as an alternative to traditional financial advisory services. The company manages a diversified, continually rebalanced portfolio of index funds on their clients’…