Free speech row as US TV channel forces removal of tweets

Guardian Web |

A US TV channel has forced Twitter to remove tweets linking to a news story about pirated content – including tweets from free speech campaigners complaining that the social network was removing other people’s tweets.

Starz, the network that airs American Gods, The 100 and Knightfall in the US, sent the takedown requests after the copyright and privacy news site TorrentFreak reported on a leak of promotional copies of those TV shows and others. TorrentFreak’s story did not contain any links to the pirated material, although it did include four screenshots of the content in order to report the alleged source of the leak.

But when TorrentFreak tweeted a link to the news story, Starz sent Twitter a legal demand to remove the tweet, alleging it infringed the company’s copyright because it linked to a website depicting “images of unreleased episodes … and information about their illegal availability”.

TorrentFreak disputed the takedown request, arguing that “our article only includes a single identifiable frame from a leaked American Gods episode, to show the screener watermarks, which are central to the story. That’s just 0.001% of the episode in question, without audio, which is generally seen as fair use, especially in a news context.”

The Electronic FrontierFoundation, US-based internet rights group, tweeted its support, noting that the article “is a far cry … from an infringement”. The media journalist Mathew Ingram also tweeted the news, calling it “disturbing”.

Both of those tweets were also removed after requests from Starz. Ingram sent another tweet criticising the removal of his tweet criticising the removal of TorrentFreaks’ tweet. That tweet was also removed after a request from Starz.

Under the US Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), copyright holders can file takedown requests to companies hosting user-generated content, informing them of infringement and requiring them to remove the content. If a user believes they have been wrongly censored, they can file a counter-claim, explaining why the content is not infringement, and requiring the host to restore it. The EFF says it has done so.

“DMCA claims can be intimidating, especially to people who don’t know the ins and outs of the process … we’ll keep calling out abusive takedowns and helping people defend their rights to speak on the internet,” the EFF said in a statement.

Twitter and Starz did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Using the DMCA takedown process to force content to be removed is a common issue on social media. In 2013, Straight Pride UK, a Russian front that supported homophobic laws in Britain, forced the blogging platform WordPress to remove an interview, eventually sparking a two-year court case.

Even legitimate takedown requests have proved controversial. Earlier this month, Warner Bros forced Twitter to remove a video posted bythe US president, Donald Trump, which reused some music from a Batman film without permission. In a statement, Warner Bros said: “The use of Warner Bros’ score from The Dark Knight Rises in the campaign video was unauthorised. We are working through the appropriate legal channels to have it removed.”

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions. To read our full disclosure, please go to:



Symbol Last Price Change % Change










World Economic Forum at Davos 2019 - Dr Oliver Krause Founder Untitled Inc Part 1

Matt Bird sits down with Dr Oliver Krause, Founder Untitled Inc, in part 1 of this 2 part interview at the World Economic Forum at Davos 2019