Fed Action: Much Ado About Very Little

Guild Investment Management  |

The much-awaited action by the Fed Thursday was… no action. The Fed mentioned that they saw no reason to raise interest rates at this time. They went on to say that the majority of voters on the Fed agreed that rates would rise before the end of the year. They cited a gradually improving and slowly growing U.S. economy, with a rate of growth slightly above 2 percent for the first half of 2015. We and many others believe that the U.S. economy is strengthening, and we expect that economic growth to exceed 3 percent in the second half of 2015. 

The only negative that we could see as a result of Thursday’s announcement is that the ongoing concern about a rate increase will dog the U.S. market for a few more months. That said, we doubt that the market will see a rise in rates as a continuing significant problem as time passes, because “news fatigue” will set in. How will news fatigue work? For example, Greece is having an election this weekend and no one cares. We remember how everyone was fixated on Greece a few months ago. The crisis passed, and the media frenzy has dissipated. 

We believe that U.S. interest rates will rise by December or early 2016, but we also note that the Fed’s internal estimates of the level of interest rates in December 2016 and Dec 2017 have both fallen, and voting members of the Fed see little inflation until 2018, when inflation is projected to reach 2 percent.

Two other points: the Fed mentioned that economic volatility in emerging markets, including China, and the big decline in commodity prices in recent weeks, had both influenced their decision to slightly delay the rise in rates. 

Our summary: Positive for stocks. The season for market corrections continues, but will soon draw to an end. We have been gradually adding to stock positions recently in expectation of stronger growth in the U.S. and the U.S. Dollar, which for the last 3 months has not risen in value. Both stronger growth and a less rapidly rising Dollar will aid in the improvement of corporate profits and provide an impetus for higher stock prices.

Market Summary

The U.S.

We are in the seasonally difficult period for U.S. equities, and we just had a correction of 12 percent as measured by the S&P 500. U.S. equity market corrections of 10 percent or more outside of recessions are rare. This was the most recent of only 13 such corrections over the last 65 years during periods when unemployment was falling. 

As regular readers know, three fears drove the market decline. First, China and EM growth rate slowing. Second, potential Fed rate hikes in September. And third, commodity price declines.

We believe that the correction may retest its lows (or retest them partially, stopping at a higher level than the previous bottom), but that the correction’s worst is over. Economists agree that the U.S. is not in a recession. After such “corrections outside of recessions” end, bottoms take time, but recoveries are strong on average: 10 percent after 3 months, and 19 percent after 6 months. Even if this recovery is slightly below normal, it will provide substantial price appreciation.

One fear is deflation, and some fear that lower commodity prices are an indication that deflation is imminent. Why have commodity prices -- and the profits of commodity producers in the U.S. -- fallen? Economists agree that demand for many commodities in unit terms is up, but a higher Dollar has cut the price per unit in U.S. Dollar terms even if it is up in local terms. A second cause of falling commodity prices is increased production, especially in oil. Overall commodity price declines in the U.S. are much more a reflection of a strong Dollar than of a decrease in demand for commodities.

The next fear concerns an interest rate hike, which did not occur Thursday and which is unlikely to occur until December at the earliest. Some fear that a rate hike will raise the value of the Dollar yet further, and thus hurt corporate profit growth in the U.S. This fear is not entirely justified; the Dollar’s rate of change has been so fast over the last year that it even if the Dollar were to rise another 10 percent in the next year, the rate of change over the next year will decline from the current rate of appreciation. Thus, the high Dollar pressure on commodities and export profits will be less in the coming year. The first Fed Funds interest rate hike, is now unlikely to occur until December at the earliest.

Then there is the fear that Chinese and EM growth rates are slowing. This is a fact, and one that has been known for many years. China’s growth rate began to slow 5 years ago, and the world media has consistently reported on the slowing for years (from an annual growth rate above 10 to12 percent to one nearer 5 to 7 percent). Some math helps us out here. The huge increase in the size of China’s economy means that with a 7 percent growth rate, China’s economy does more to help global growth than the 12 percent growth rate they enjoyed 10 years ago!

Europe and U.S Stocks

We are neutral to slightly positive on Europe, and believe that European stock markets will gradually appreciate. How will Europe pay its debts and generate growth? The same way sovereign countries always have -- inflation. It’s only a matter of time.

Within the U.S., we favor technology, internet-related, software, biotechnology, pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, financial companies, homebuilders, and financial services.

Emerging Markets

Emerging markets remain unattractive because their profits are not growing in U.S. Dollar terms. Their profits are rising, but their currencies are falling virus the U.S. Dollar, thus cancelling out the positive effects of the profit increases for U.S. investors.


Gold very much depends on the Dollar; once the Dollar stops rising, gold will rally. It has been rising in terms of the Euro and Yen in recent months.

Investment implications: We believe that although a full or partial retest of recent lows may occur, the correction’s worst is over, and if the past is a guide, U.S. stocks will appreciate over the next six-month timeframe. We think that the psychological fears that drove the correction are based on misinterpretations of the fundamental economic data. Commodity price declines are being driven by supply and a strong Dollar, not by collapsing demand, although demand is not growing as fast as in the past. A Fed rate hike in the coming months may give the Dollar more strength, but its rate of appreciation is likely to slow over the coming year. China’s growth, although slowing, remains robust and supportive of the global economy. Within the U.S., we favor technology, internet-related, software, biotechnology, pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, financial companies, homebuilders, and financial services.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions. To read our full disclosure, please go to: http://www.equities.com/disclaimer



Symbol Last Price Change % Change










Can the Media Solve the Partisan Conflict?

Andrew McCarthy, Contributing Editor, The National Review; Michael Zeldin, CNN Legal Analyst; Celeste Katz, Senior Political Reporter, Glamour; Silvia Davi, SVP, Contributing Editor, Equities.com; and Doug Simon, CEO, D S Simon Media discuss how the media’s role has shaped the landscape for communicators and what the media is trying to do to reduce discord in society.

Emerging Growth

Permanent Techs Inc

Permanent Technologies Inc engages in the design and manufacture of multi-faceted, vibration-proof, self-locking nut and bolt systems for use in the fastener industry in the United States. The Company also…