Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


Breaking Up Microsoft (MSFT) is a No-Brainer

  +Follow December 12, 2013 8:44AM
Tickers Mentioned:

In one of the most famous scenes of the movie Wall Street antagonist Gordon Gekko explains to neophyte trader Bud Fox why he decided he was going to liquidate the fictional Bluestar Airline: “Because it’s wreckable.”

He did not mean it’s wreckable in the sense that something should be destroyed because it can be destroyed, but rather that that the company was worth more to the world in pieces than as a whole. And actually, with large companies, this is very often the case.

The kernel of truth in the unrepentant capitalist Gekko’s statement is that often, monolithic companies have become lumbering giants, inefficient behemoths that lack focus and waste billions supporting an overweight structure.

Sound like Microsoft (MSFT) ? And the truth is if Microsoft were ever to be broken up, billions in potential value could be unlocked.

Kill the Beast! Kill the Beast!

Microsoft is one of the most unwieldy companies on the planet. It is a burgeoning mass made up of a famously uncooperative mass of disparate departments, united in name only.

There’s their software division. There’s their video game division and the reasonably successful Xbox series. There’s the unmitigated stinking disaster that is Bing. Not to mention tablets and the expected foray into smartphones following the Nokia acquisition.

That’s a lot of different directions to go in. And it comes at a time when the company is about to lose its bald head, the much derided Steve Ballmer.

The question for stockholders is what the most profitable decision is: trying to find someone who can maneuver the company over all that ground, or end the once undisputed king of tech into smaller, less dominant, but theoretically more nimble compenents?

Not “One Micorsoft,” But Two, or Three…

Several months ago Ballmer announced the “One Microsoft” initiative, aimed at directing the company in a coherent direction. At the same time, pundits were already imagining what it would look like to take the ax to Microsoft and split it like a cord of wood.

Analysts imagined at first a clean split of the company: one consumer tech (Windows, Office, Xbox) and one business-centric (SharePoint, Azure, Dynamics).  But since fall 2013, analyst opinion has begun to include the ideas of splitting Microsoft into even smaller, more specialized parts.

Jim Cramer suggested splitting Microsoft into three businesses: a software business; and “entertainment” business to handle the likes of Xbox; and a cellphone business – essentially, Nokia with more capital. Presumably, this would mean ending the multi-billion dollar failure of Bing, a proposition some of Ballmer’s possible successors have floated.

The value unlocked in this kind of breakup would be massive. Killing Bing alone would put an end to billions in lost income. And refocusing software could help reasserts Microsoft’s position in operating systems, a market currently dominated by Apple Inc. (AAPL) .

But it’s not just pundits calling for Microsoft’s head. It’s also one of the founders.

On Nov. 4 Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen’s money manager, reportedly speaking for Mr. Allen, called search and Xbox a “distraction” and recommended spinning them off.

How Much Could be Unlocked?

That’s the million dollar question. Or, more likely, multi-billion dollar question.

Rick Sherlund, an analyst at Nomura Securities, suggested if Microsoft spun off Bing and Xbox, they could increase their dividend to a whopping 6 percent, making it the highest-yielding large cap tech company for stockholders.

Others have argued that an “online services” division, comprised of Bing, MSN, and adCenter costs the company $8.1 billion a year in losses. Spinning off those companies alone would allow a massive buyback, dividend increase, or possibly both. The exact value derived from a breakup is uncertain, but there's little reason to believe it wouldn't total in the billions.

Is There a Reason to Keep Microsoft Whole?

Breaking up is hard to do, and in the case of multibillion dollar behemoths, is almost irreversible. Once the decision is made to split, the company can’t really go back on it. Once Xbox or Bing is sold off to another company, you can’t exactly ask for it back. So is there value in keeping it together?

To be sure, Microsoft’s stock this year has not been an outright disappointment. A 37.98 percent return on the year has it outpacing the gains of the otherwise robust S&P 500. And only the largest of companies can do things like institute $40 billion dollar buybacks.

Breaking up also might be easier said than done. Preston Gralla of ComputerWorld argues that Bing, however costly, is too integral to their other products to ever be killed.

But just because Microsoft has increased in value, and just because the poisonous Bing has wormed its way into several other lines, does not means more value won't be extracted long term form extrication. revenue does not mean more could not be unlocked via breakup.

And it’s almost impossible to argue that Microsoft’s incredibly disparate departments work better together. The corproate culture there is notoriously toxic, and there has been little indication "One Microsoft" has rectified this.

Microsoft should pick their next successor soon. The best thing he or she could do is take Microsoft and take the hammer to it.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Liked What You Read? Join Equities.com and Connect With Your Favorite Financial Experts FOR FREE! Members of Equities.com gain access to our leading financial news and content, active social investment community, proprietary research tools including the 2014 Small-Cap Stars, E.V.A. reports and more.

Results for MSFT
26 Oct 14 01:12:30
Microsoft Corp (MSFT) 46.13 $MSFT The 12 Ugliest Phones of the Mobile Era at The Street - Sat Oct 25, 10:25AM http://t.co/uiA4Nran7X
26 Oct 14 00:30:10
Hedge Funds Trimming: $NYT $PENN $PII $TTM $APOL $EXPD $FL $VWO $WYN $CRZO $CLX $FHN $PBR $MSFT $WFC http://t.co/XQITF0lRKD #mkt #analyst
Paul W. Mahon
26 Oct 14 00:04:12
RT @SeekingAlpha: Are XLK And Its Holdings Overpriced? http://t.co/m0iuzkLTDj $AAPL #APPLE $CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ $…
25 Oct 14 23:00:05
Unusual Options Activity: Calls: $KING $POT $TER $KLAC $HUN $WTW $CBI $CTXS $ORCL $UA $UPS $BMY $XCO $AMZN $MSFT http://t.co/Vv2VEn80mr
Julián A. Murillo
25 Oct 14 22:19:58
ReTw lexinerus: ReTw lexinerus: ReTw QP_Technology: $CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ News: "Are XL... https://t.co/Y2UGfMCzFg
25 Oct 14 22:15:42
@conradhackett @clairecm - $MSFT isn't bigger in WA? Hard to believe...
Julián A. Murillo
25 Oct 14 22:09:40
ReTw lexinerus: ReTw QP_Technology: $CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ News: "Are XLK And Its Holdin... https://t.co/Y2UGfMCzFg
Julián A. Murillo
25 Oct 14 22:03:30
ReTw QP_Technology: $CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ News: "Are XLK And Its Holdings…" ... https://t.co/Y2UGfMCzFg
Joe Attrux
25 Oct 14 21:59:54
RT @SeekingAlpha: Are XLK And Its Holdings Overpriced? http://t.co/m0iuzkLTDj $AAPL #APPLE $CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ $…
Quantpost Technology
25 Oct 14 21:55:49
$CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ News: "Are XLK And Its Holdings…" http://t.co/hWol2TQBBX Board view: https://t.co/ZqMJyBJSAW
Seeking Alpha
25 Oct 14 21:55:47
Are XLK And Its Holdings Overpriced? http://t.co/m0iuzkLTDj $AAPL #APPLE $CSCO $FB $GOOG $GOOGL $IBM $INTC $MSFT $T $VZ $XLK
25 Oct 14 21:44:56
Microsoft - A Strong Buying Proposition http://t.co/aH4Br1lH1Y $MSFT $SAP $NOK http://t.co/949FdUno1G
g e
25 Oct 14 21:43:15
RT @jonfortt: $MSFT CEO @satyanadella sits down with @CNBC @SquawkAlley's Jon Fortt, full transcript: http://t.co/1S4L9trqNg
25 Oct 14 21:30:05
Microsoft : NICE Trading Recording Solution Receives Microsoft Lync Qualification http://t.co/uzbnDyW0AM $MSFT $NICE
Damien Bowman 3.2
25 Oct 14 20:13:42
Someone at $MSFT wanna hire us? RT @pigskinopinion: @damiEnbowman Work for Microsoft. There is so much of that money up there.. :)
Carpathia Capital
25 Oct 14 19:50:56
One year ago, $MSFT market PE 13.7, our Adequate PE estimate 17.1 Now stock price +30%, DEPS barely up, market PE 17.5 #howwefared
phiℓip abinya
25 Oct 14 19:13:18
RT @ericjackson: Stock returns since Jan 13th 2006: $YHOO +0.7% $MSFT +71.0% Nasdaq +94.3% $GOOGL +135.5% $AAPL +863.6%
Top Lists
25 Oct 14 19:00:43
Top 5 Stocks That Could Have Made You RICH! http://t.co/EKHe9dXNVg $fb $pcyc $MSFT $MIDD $AAPL #rich #stocks
25 Oct 14 19:00:05
Gap Ups: $WRB $FII $FET $AGU $MTX $PDFS $OCR $CTCT $MXWL $RP $MSFT $B $GIMO $FLIR $BDN http://t.co/XQITF0lRKD #markets #analyst #stocks
25 Oct 14 17:38:27
RT @BarbarianCap: this is good "Windows 10: We finally fixed everything" (via FB) $MSFT http://t.co/dG9zB40iJh
Stock Wire
25 Oct 14 17:33:10
Microsoft Corporation (MSFT) Gained More Than $60 Billion Under Nadella ... $MSFT http://t.co/zSD1Vlx0wT
Carolyn B Miciano
25 Oct 14 17:10:20
Maximize trades from Volume profile free course http://t.co/qT0STZib5F $IBM $MSFT $HPQ
Premal S. Shah
25 Oct 14 17:00:08
Looking forward to Surface-like success! $MSFT plans to launch smartwatch within weeks: The Economic Times http://t.co/AELO2ouFXt
Scott Spencer
25 Oct 14 16:47:51
$FB $MSFT $GOOG why hate illegal aliens when thousands of jobs go to overseas contractors at $500/month? #outsourcing http://t.co/1g94ns4PcK
Alonzo Garcia
25 Oct 14 16:30:36
they has been doing that any way so thats no news. http://t.co/yshIThchv5 via @daily_finance $MSFT
25 Oct 14 16:05:09
Mic : osoft OS Early Announcement Troubles (Windows 10 Release Date in USA) http://t.co/b0IguneNr8 $MSFT
25 Oct 14 16:05:03
Microsoft : Anne Arundel students get free Microsoft software http://t.co/8GE5WfsBo4 $MSFT
25 Oct 14 15:45:54
#Buy $DNAX #DNA #Energy #Drinks #New #CEO #Real #Experience > $FNMA $HEMP $PMCM $PHOT $PLPL $CBIS $JPM $GS $MS $TSLA $FB $TWTR $GOOG $MSFT
Carolyn B Miciano
25 Oct 14 15:44:56
Option Greeks are critical in Options trading http://t.co/RHx80Rp6au $IBM $MSFT $HPQ
Fleury Est
25 Oct 14 15:29:30
@jimcramer segment idea: $AAPL, $MSFT, $IBM, $XOM, $RDS.B, $WMT, $CHL, $PBR, $BABA (etc)? What are the best of the GIANT Caps?
25 Oct 14 14:50:02
Microsoft : to help with UAE’s Drones for Good Award http://t.co/M7eXuOdIKj $MSFT
Edward Gofsky
25 Oct 14 14:44:06
RT @muathe: [VIDEO] Weekend Market Analysis 10/25/14 $FB $T $BABA $AAPL $F $MSFT $ES_F $DRYS $QQQ $GM $SPY $PBR $PFE $VALE $FNFG http://t.c…
25 Oct 14 14:31:59
RT @BarbarianCap: this is good "Windows 10: We finally fixed everything" (via FB) $MSFT http://t.co/dG9zB40iJh
Carolyn B Miciano
25 Oct 14 14:07:04
The negatives of Ratio spreads http://t.co/0a90XBmekt $IBM $MSFT $HPQ
25 Oct 14 14:05:04
Microsoft : CEO Satya Nadella Gets $84 Million Pay Package http://t.co/R3iKdzlYap $MSFT
25 Oct 14 13:58:20
Our Penny Stock Alerts Gained 371% In 2 weeks! Sign Up For Free Text Alerts For Our New Pick: http://t.co/dLDRavoCi4 $MSFT $ORCL $VOD
Carolyn B Miciano
25 Oct 14 13:58:07
20% to 50% in a week or two - powerful swing trades http://t.co/yLZsCIoFks $IBM $MSFT $HPQ
25 Oct 14 13:51:46
Our Penny Stock Alerts Gained 371% In 2 weeks! Sign Up For Free Text Alerts For Our New Pick: http://t.co/dLDRavoCi4 $XLF $F $FN $MSFT
Mission: ToRun
25 Oct 14 13:50:35
RT @AlphaHatInc: Investors are more bearish on Microsoft $MSFT than Apple $AAPL http://t.co/ZsVP4wBRYn via @AlphaHatInc #AlphaHat #FinTech
25 Oct 14 13:42:10
@danielhsqr $MSFT Sold 9.3M Nokia Smartphones (I mean Lumia) $BBRY sold 2.1M $AAPL sold 39.3M. Are those sales # are weekly, monthly, QT?
Carolyn B Miciano
25 Oct 14 13:23:55
Detailed study of Option Greeks http://t.co/RHx80Rp6au $IBM $MSFT $HPQ
25 Oct 14 13:18:12
RT @TheStreet: It appears CEO Nadella is infusing new DNA Microsoft's strong earnings report: http://t.co/NmLxRKIP2g $MSFT via @jbruin
Alpha Hat
25 Oct 14 13:18:00
Investors are more bearish on Microsoft $MSFT than Apple $AAPL http://t.co/ZsVP4wBRYn via @AlphaHatInc #AlphaHat #FinTech
Capital Oversight
25 Oct 14 13:16:09
RT @TheStreet: It appears CEO Nadella is infusing new DNA Microsoft's strong earnings report: http://t.co/NmLxRKIP2g $MSFT via @jbruin
25 Oct 14 13:04:34
RT TheStreet: It appears CEO Nadella is infusing new DNA Microsoft's strong earnings report: http://t.co/JjzrgIhobJ  $MSFT via jbruin
Alysia Sarkisian
25 Oct 14 12:51:56
RT @TheStreet: It appears CEO Nadella is infusing new DNA Microsoft's strong earnings report: http://t.co/NmLxRKIP2g $MSFT via @jbruin
Media Sentiment
25 Oct 14 12:49:49
$MSFT received a new alert. Find out why at http://t.co/5udYd0Ofs6 #stocks #daytrading #trading #mkt #NYSE #NASDAQ #markets 29
25 Oct 14 12:46:49
RT @TheStreet: It appears CEO Nadella is infusing new DNA Microsoft's strong earnings report: http://t.co/NmLxRKIP2g $MSFT via @jbruin
25 Oct 14 12:45:06
It appears CEO Nadella is infusing new DNA Microsoft's strong earnings report: http://t.co/NmLxRKIP2g $MSFT via @jbruin
25 Oct 14 12:30:10
Hedge Funds Trimming: $NYT $PENN $PII $TTM $APOL $EXPD $FL $VWO $WYN $CRZO $CLX $FHN $PBR $MSFT $WFC http://t.co/XQITF0lRKD #stockmarket
  +Follow December 12, 2013 8:44AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.