logo  
Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?

Register
    

Has the Dow Jones Industrial Average Become Irrelevant?

By  +Follow June 27, 2013 3:39PM
Share:
Tickers Mentioned:

Charles Henry DowFounded by Charles Dow in 1896, the Dow Jones Industrial Average follows the price performance of 30 large, publically traded American companies. Since its creation, the Dow has served as one of the world’s most acknowledged financial indices, and is commonly displayed on the front page of newspapers and financial websites worldwide.                              

From industrials to technology and financials to retailers, the Dow is designed to represent a complete, well-balanced picture of how American large-cap stocks perform on a given day. The current list of Dow holdings can be found here, courtesy of CNN.

While the Dow’s longevity is indicative of its historical effectiveness and importance, many of its methods are antiquated in today’s day and age. The following information is intended to explain how the Dow Jones Industrial Average works and why it may need an overhaul.

The Dow’s System of Weights

The amount of weight that one company carries in the Dow is determined by the price of its stock. While the formula can get convoluted with stock splits and dividend payments, individual stock prices remain the primary determinant of index weight. For instance, a $100 stock carries 10 times more value than a $10 stock, regardless of value or relative importance of the two companies.

Given the weights of these five Dow stocks, it’s easy to see why this system has drawn heavy criticism over the years.

DJIA Weighting

 

Although IBM (IBM) is worth 25 percent less than Microsoft (MSFT), it carries six times more weight. As a result, IBM carries enough weight to singlehandedly move the index with a significant price movement, while Microsoft, a more valuable and equally relevant company, is negligible.

Meanwhile, Alcoa (AA) and Bank of America (BAC) both hold weights of around 0.5 percent, although Bank of America is worth approximately 17 times more.

This price-weighting system also means that $1 changes in Bank of America and a $1 change in IBM moves the Dow by the same amount. However, in reality, a $1 price increase in Bank of America creates $10 billion in market value, which is 10 times more than a $1 change in IBM. Perhaps this illogicality means that it’s time for the Dow to follow in the footsteps of the S&P 500 and Nasdaq, which use market capitalizations to determine stock weights.

The Stocks in the Dow

One of the Dow’s strengths is its broad range of stock components. The Dow has just about everything: healthcare providers, automakers, financials, retailers, tech companies, utilities, and so on.

What the Dow lacks, however, is four of America’s most influential and valuable companies – Apple (AAPL), Google (GOOG), Amazon (AMZN) and Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A).

Although all four companies are worthy of becoming Dow components, the price-weighting model sparks complications. Apple would account for almost 20 percent of the Dow, Google 40 percent, and Amazon 13 percent. Berkshire Hathaway’s $169,000 stock price would make up almost the entire index.

This is an obvious shortcoming because these companies are too important not to include in the world’s most popular large cap index. Apple, Google, and Amazon are perhaps the greatest innovators of the last decade and are among the world’s largest revenue earners, yet they have no plans to join the Dow.

Leaving America’s greatest innovators and largest companies out substantiates the index as incomplete. The Dow is known as a large cap index, yet its model ironically omits America’s largest companies.                                                                                         

History vs. Reason

With all of its shortcomings and inconsistencies, why does the Dow remain so highly regarded?  Nicholas Colas, chief market strategist at ConvergEx, told Fox Business in January that fascination with the Dow starts and ends with history.

“The Dow has one existential advantage: it’s the oldest. Before the Federal Reserve existed you had a Dow Jones Industrial Average,” said Colas.  “There’s actual value to that. If you want to understand how stocks traded in the Depression, you’ve got one choice and it’s the Dow.”

Jamie Farmer, managing director of S&P Dow Jones Indices, agrees with Colas. “Extensive history allows for a referential touchstone. We’ve got so much history, the actual number we see provides a great deal of value. We know intuitively where the (Dow’s) number is.”

Although the Dow certainly has a rich history, it’s obvious that the index has lost some of its relevancy and needs to make significant adjustments to its pricing-weighting model.  Until that day arrives, investors would be prudent to actively follow the market cap-weighted S&P 500 instead of the Dow to gage market activity.

People have grown used to the Dow dominating financial headlines, but the index just is no longer relevant enough to warrant its current level of financial attention.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.


Liked What You Read? Join Equities.com and Connect With Your Favorite Financial Experts FOR FREE! Members of Equities.com gain access to our leading financial news and content, active social investment community, proprietary research tools including the 2014 Small-Cap Stars, E.V.A. reports and more.

Results for ^DJI
DJI Forums
22 Sep 14 09:16:00
RT @recuerdorecord: Responsable. Dji Phantom Zenmuse h3-2d Gopro Hero3 Black Edition HD http://t.co/bB2sOVmQJy
Chris Cheong
22 Sep 14 09:15:35
@shjackcharts @AslanEkmekci $DJI 0.382 Supp from the lows (16,937) holding. seems like a Bounce is coming up!
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 09:15:14
Get Your 7-day Free Trial $ES_F Live Trading Room Visit http://t.co/Z6SZ3H2SeS $SPY $FB $NQ_F $SPX $YM_F $TSLA $NFLX $TWT $QQQ $DJI
Emini Scalping
22 Sep 14 09:11:43
Just Imagine if you could Find market's Intraday Highs and Lows for $ES_F #dayTrading $SPX $SPY $DJI $AAPL $QQQ $IWM
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 09:11:42
$ES_F $SPX $SPY $DJI $QQQ $YM_F $NQ_F $TF_F $FB did your Trade get Stopped Out because of The Market's noises? we can help you to avoid it!
Dave L.
22 Sep 14 09:10:52
RT @LexarMemory: GIVEAWAY ALERT! Visit our Facebook page for your chance to win a DJI Phantom 2 Vision+ Quadcopter! Details: http://t.co/Qy…
dronzworld
22 Sep 14 09:10:43
Another picture from our flight last night! #Hollywood #DJI #Drones #Phantom2 @Djiglobal http://t.co/J7zY22z1Ne
EMini Futures
22 Sep 14 09:10:31
A business with no staff,no customers,no inventory,no rent&could literally be operated from anywhere in the world $SPX $SPY $DJI $QQQ $ES_F
A Finer Life
22 Sep 14 09:09:18
DJI Phantom FC40 Quadcopter UAV RC #Drone w/ Wifi Camera for Aerial Photography http://t.co/bxdJ5WzIrH #AerialPhotography
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 09:08:46
7day free trial for 5years Old Live Trading Room $ES_F #ES_F $SPY $SPX $DJI $QQQ $IWM http://t.co/j2jdBgQAtR
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 09:08:36
Just Imagine if you could Find market's Intraday Highs and Lows for $ES_F #dayTrading $SPX $SPY $DJI $AAPL $QQQ $IWM
@GogoLesta
22 Sep 14 09:08:25
Deals #003 http://t.co/h4cpmmUUli New Shoulder Bag Carrying Case Backpack For DJI Phantom1/2,Vision2,FC40 $48.00   $68.99   (22 Availa...
@GogoLesta
22 Sep 14 09:08:06
Deals #003 http://t.co/pSlj99yq0g Shoulder Bag Quadcopter Backpack for DJI Phantom 1 / 2 Vision,FC40 $48.00   $68.99   (500 Available)...
DronesDaily
22 Sep 14 09:07:54
Hovering over Waveny Park in #Connecticut. #dronesdaily #lowceiling #drones #dji #phantom2 #zenmuse… http://t.co/7QZ4xlWj7o
Recuerdo Registrado
22 Sep 14 09:07:23
Responsable. Dji Phantom Zenmuse h3-2d Gopro Hero3 Black Edition HD http://t.co/bB2sOVmQJy
DJI Forums
22 Sep 14 09:07:07
RT @LexarMemory: GIVEAWAY ALERT! Visit our Facebook page for your chance to win a DJI Phantom 2 Vision+ Quadcopter! Details: http://t.co/Qy…
B3dgeable
22 Sep 14 09:06:59
DJI Phantom 2 Vision+ Plus Quadcopter + Extra Battery ... - http://t.co/BeAG6asGl6 #3dprinting http://t.co/8FPPQBSbQ1
FinanzLinksUSA
22 Sep 14 09:05:32
RT @SPDJIndices: Mid-day: SP500 1992.82 -17.58 | DJI 17198.50 -81.24 | DJC 6111.23 -46.73 | DJT 8518.25 -115.58 | DJU 553.05 -3.86 | GDOW 2…
Stefano Saldarelli
22 Sep 14 09:05:03
Uno sguardo alla baia di Sydney attraverso l'occhio vigile del DJI Global Phantom 2 Vision Plus... http://t.co/VYSITg4qdb
dark lord donidius
22 Sep 14 09:04:54
RT @ScalpingAcademy: $ES_F $SPX $SPY $DJI $QQQ $YM_F $NQ_F $TF_F $FB did your Trade get Stopped Out because of The Market's noises? we can…
Ezabil Deals
22 Sep 14 09:03:56
http://t.co/iQgO9DEt0X #Deals #8384 DJI Phantom 2 Vision UAV Drone Quadcopter 5200 mAh 11.1V Battery CP.PT.0000... http://t.co/2TLgy9zx3H
VEGA Deals
22 Sep 14 09:03:29
http://t.co/jtGJzwTVa1 #Deals #8510 DJI Phantom 2 Vision UAV Drone Quadcopter 5200 mAh 11.1V Battery CP.PT.0000... http://t.co/UrlNTMPSny
Emini Scalping
22 Sep 14 09:03:04
$ES_F $SPX $SPY $DJI $QQQ $YM_F $NQ_F $TF_F $FB did your Trade get Stopped Out because of The Market's noises? we can help you to avoid it!
FINE DEALS
22 Sep 14 09:02:38
New Deals : http://t.co/q4Cy23rsKR #3281 DJI Phantom Drone Propeller Protector Bumper Prop Guards (Set of 4) CP... http://t.co/1f4fikQYy1
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 09:02:37
$ES_F $SPX $SPY $DJI $QQQ $YM_F $NQ_F $TF_F $FB did your Trade get Stopped Out because of The Market's noises? we can help you to avoid it!
Stefanos D. Poulis
22 Sep 14 09:02:13
#US #USmarket #Markets RT “@SPDJIndices: Mid-day: #SP500 1992.82 -17.58 | #DJI 17198.50 -81.24”
DSP Capital
22 Sep 14 09:02:12
#US #USmarket #Markets RT “@SPDJIndices: Mid-day: #SP500 1992.82 -17.58 | #DJI 17198.50 -81.24”
kanu
22 Sep 14 09:01:18
Fallow dji http://t.co/tg3OJH72nU
S&PDowJonesIndices
22 Sep 14 09:01:02
Mid-day: SP500 1992.82 -17.58 | DJI 17198.50 -81.24 | DJC 6111.23 -46.73 | DJT 8518.25 -115.58 | DJU 553.05 -3.86 | GDOW 2581.47 -23.12
Дмитрий Ожигаев
22 Sep 14 09:00:24
Помогите скрипт установить http://t.co/1ThTis6PKw
Дмитрий Ожигаев
22 Sep 14 09:00:09
— Я спас тебе жизнь! — Ты не спас мне жизнь, ты исковеркал мне смерть!
VIP OFFERS
22 Sep 14 08:59:51
http://t.co/pLFjlSRndD #Deals #0106 DJI Phantom 2 Vision UAV Drone Quadcopter Self-Tightening Propeller CP.PT.0... http://t.co/boEsJCwa5R
Lexar
22 Sep 14 08:59:15
GIVEAWAY ALERT! Visit our Facebook page for your chance to win a DJI Phantom 2 Vision+ Quadcopter! Details: http://t.co/QyqERNAXSs
EMini Futures
22 Sep 14 08:59:14
7day free trial for 5years Old Live Trading Room $ES_F #ES_F $SPY $SPX $DJI $QQQ $IWM http://t.co/nWcvguzs9C
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 08:58:22
Just Imagine if you could Find market's Intraday Highs and Lows for $ES_F #dayTrading $SPX $SPY $DJI $AAPL $QQQ $IWM
DJI Forums
22 Sep 14 08:57:51
RT @Dokia_Offers: DOKIA OFFERS > http://t.co/4cGL5BRH6O #74320 Quadcopter Universal Shoulder Bag Backpack for DJI Phantom 1 / 2 V... http:/…
DJI Forums
22 Sep 14 08:57:51
RT @aerialindonesia: Perfectly smooth aerial video! http://t.co/d3iYOYtF4l #aerialcinematography #showreel #aerialindonesia shot with a DJI…
miúda espetacular ☯
22 Sep 14 08:57:25
o novo som do dji tafinha tá um same, mesmo same caralho
ManUtd-PSG®
22 Sep 14 08:55:50
Sa rentre sa allume la play c'est la base frère
Zonebourse News
22 Sep 14 08:55:04
LES Marchés à la clôture en Europe http://t.co/MA4UMnd3pf $PX1 $DAX $NDX $SMI $DJI $COMP $S500 $SMI
Crisna Nugraha
22 Sep 14 08:55:02
RT @B3dge: DJI Phantom 2 Vision+ Plus Quadcopter + Extra Battery ... - http://t.co/yPgQIvFVBJ #3dprinting http://t.co/pbedrXxHHq
DOKIA OFFERS
22 Sep 14 08:54:46
DOKIA OFFERS > http://t.co/T08Dw2hcIL #74320 DJI Phantom Replacement 2200 mAh 11.1V 3s LiPo Flight Battery w/ X... http://t.co/VZFnBrhwi9
DOKIA OFFERS
22 Sep 14 08:54:42
DOKIA OFFERS > http://t.co/4cGL5BRH6O #74320 Quadcopter Universal Shoulder Bag Backpack for DJI Phantom 1 / 2 V... http://t.co/84hGjHKDvP
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 08:54:24
Just Imagine if you could Find market's Intraday Highs and Lows for $ES_F #dayTrading $SPX $SPY $DJI $AAPL $QQQ $IWM
EMini Futures
22 Sep 14 08:54:21
Get Your 7-day Free Trial $ES_F Live Trading Room Visit http://t.co/TVcNGpes4X $SPY $FB $NQ_F $SPX $YM_F $TSLA $NFLX $TWT $QQQ $DJI
Iain Cranston
22 Sep 14 08:52:09
RT @MarionvilleRC: Amazing shots of Scotland from one of our customers. Checkout his show real. All shot from the DJI Phantom2 http://t.co/…
Winborn Traders
22 Sep 14 08:51:32
Get Your 7-day Free Trial $ES_F Live Trading Room Visit http://t.co/1YUYrFnnrb $SPY $FB $NQ_F $SPX $YM_F $TSLA $NFLX $TWT $QQQ $DJI
Tim Moore
22 Sep 14 08:50:56
RT @WTEric: Our social media mgr - @RonPloof: @TimMoore It took longer than expected. My response to your DJI video challenge http://t.co/f…
aerialindo
22 Sep 14 08:50:15
Perfectly smooth aerial video! http://t.co/d3iYOYtF4l #aerialcinematography #showreel #aerialindonesia shot with a DJI S800
@BekamDonfer
22 Sep 14 08:50:04
Deals #809 http://t.co/9ahfOw51yU New Shoulder Bag Carrying Case Backpack For DJI Phantom1/2,Vision2,FC40 $48.00   $68.99   (22 Availa...
				
				
By  +Follow June 27, 2013 3:39PM
Share:

Comments

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.