Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


What is Obamacare? Part I: Exchanges

By  +Follow September 19, 2013 9:13AM
Tickers Mentioned:

Republicans in the House of Representatives fired another salvo on Wednesday in their ongoing effort to destroy 2010’s Affordable Care Act, passing a bill that ties continued funding of the government to the defunding of the health care reform. Like past efforts, it appears dead on arrival, but just the fact that Republicans are willing to launch this H-hour attempt to kill the law speaks to how controversial it’s become.

However, despite no lack of strong opinions, what might be most notable about health care reform is the confusion surrounding it. Despite a raucous public debate, a great many people still fail to understand the most basic elements of the law. A recent Pew/USA Today poll found that 51 percent of responders didn’t realize that low-income individuals and families would be eligible for subsidies with another 49 percent believing that there wouldn’t be an exchange in their state (every state will have an exchange).

Whatever the end result, health care reform should have a major effect on the health care sector and the economy overall. So, in the first of a series, here’s a look at Obamacare in all its glory (or lack thereof).

One Giant Risk Pool

The basic operating principle in the creation of health insurance exchanges was the expansion of risk pools. In the past, when insurance companies agreed to insure someone, it involved a careful consideration of risk and how much it’s likely to cost them. Unfortunately, this meant that if you had obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure, and depression (which was understandable given your obesity, diabetes, and high blood pressure), an insurance company would most likely refuse to insure you for anything less than a small fortune. You were a risk pool of one, and it was a very risky pool indeed.

However, if you got a job at a major corporation and joined their health plan, your employer would pay a much lower rate to insure you than you could ever hope for on your own. That’s because despite your sky-high medical costs, the guy in the cubicle next to you with his green tea and daily yoga sessions is costing the insurance company next to nothing, basically balancing you out. And once you spread everyone’s risks and costs out across a few hundred or a few thousand people, your insurance company could come back with a reasonable rate for everyone that wouldn’t break the bank for your employer and wouldn’t run the insurance company into financial ruin.

Now, the government is essentially getting the insurance industry to treat everyone in America without insurance through their job as one giant risk pool, evening out premiums in the same way they would in the large group market. To do this, the law creates a system of incentives to convince uninsured people to get health insurance as well as a central hub in each state, the exchange, where customers can go to shop for health plans.

Obamacare Subsidies

For many, if not most, uninsured Americans, one of the primary barriers to getting insurance has always been cost. To combat this, the law has created subsidies available to any individual or family making between 133 and 400 percent of the federal poverty level. The poverty level varies depending on family size (or if you live in Alaska or Hawaii), but that’s between $15,281.70 and $45,960 for an individual and between $31,321.50 and $94,200 for a family of four.

The size of the subsidies are on a sliding scale based on income, but they will essentially cap premiums for the exchange’s “benchmark plan” (more on this later) at between 3 percent and 9.5 percent of income, with the government picking up any cost of premiums that would exceed that level. So if you make $15,281.70 a year, you could get the benchmark plan at the exchange, pay $458 a year (3 percent of your income) in premiums, and the balance would be paid by Uncle Sam. And if you make $45,960 a year, you would pay up to $4,275 a year (9.5 percent of your income) for the benchmark plan, and the rest of your premium (if any) would be paid by the subsidy.

For people making less than 133 percent of the poverty level, the law initially expanded Medicaid to give them coverage at no cost to them. However, the Supreme Court ruled that the federal government didn’t have the authority force states to accept this expansion. So, for those states rejecting the expansion, subsidies will extend down to anyone making the federal poverty level (with premiums for the benchmark plan capped at 2% of income for those making between 100 and 133 percent of the poverty level). However, some individuals making less than $11,000 a year won’t have access to federal insurance subsidies to purchase their own insurance and won't be eligible for Medicaid.

Individual Mandate

While the availability of subsidies is likely more than enough to attract many of those currently uninsured, many others may still not see the need. Even with the lower post-subsidy rates, many young, healthy people could look at the premiums and decide that they’re better off foregoing coverage. This may not seem like a major issue, but it would be something of a disaster for the whole idea of one massive risk pool. The reason risk pools are advantageous is because there are healthier people who are more profitable for the insurer to balance out the less healthy people who are costing the insurer. This is even more important now because the Affordable Care Act says that insurers can neither reject an individual or family for coverage nor charge them a different rate because of their medical history. Meaning they don’t really have a choice in the matter. And if no young, healthy people decide to get insurance, it would leave insurance companies with a much riskier pool than they signed on for.

To combat this, the law created a new tax on people who don’t have insurance. The idea being that it would create a financial incentive for even the youngest, healthiest people to go out and get insurance and balance out the risk pool for the higher-risk, higher-cost people who don't need any extra incentive. The penalty is going to be the higher of either 1 percent of an individual’s income or a flat fee of $95 for the 2014 tax year, increase to the higher of $325 or 2 percent of income for the 2015 tax year, and settle into the higher of $695 or 2.5 percent of income for the 2016 tax year and beyond (though the fee will be adjusted as time goes on based on certain federal benchmarks). So, someone making $50,000 a year and opting not to get health insurance should pay $500 the first year, $1,000 the second, and $2,000 thereafter. Certain group are exempted, but the majority of those people who are uninsured could have a nasty surprise on their tax bill if they don't take action.


The final piece of these new risk pools comes in the form of the exchanges. Each state will have its own marketplace where consumers can go to shop for health plans. Health plans will be organized into metal tiers, with plans being categorized as bronze, silver, gold, or platinum (so it's like the Olympics, but better). These tiers reflect how much cost-sharing the plans include in the form of things like copays, coinsurance, and deductibles. Bronze plans will have the highest cost-sharing, but this should mean that they’ll also have the lowest premiums. Platinum plans, meanwhile, will require relatively little cost-sharing but should have much higher premiums. The “benchmark” plan used to set the size of a person’s subsidy would be the second-cheapest plan at the silver level. This means that, once the size of the subsidy is set using the benchmark plan’s premiums and the purchaser's income, that person can still opt for lower-premium bronze plans (or that one cheaper silver plan) without reducing the size of their subsidy.

Every state will have an exchange, but states had the option to run their own exchange, run an exchange as part of a partnership with the federal government, or let the federal government run the exchange. So, even if your state's governor has spent the last three years railing against Obamacare, your state will still have an exchange. 

How Will Obamacare Affect Insurance Companies?

Among those watching what happens on Oct. 1 the closest will be insurance companies, including industry leaders like Unitedhealth Group, Inc. (UNH) , WellPoint, Inc. (WLP) , Aetna, Inc. (AET) , Cigna Corp. (CI) , and Humana, Inc. (HUM) . These companies are participating in different state exchanges on a selective basis, carefully trying to determine just what the new individual markets will look like. In many cases, they’ve already set the premiums on the plans they will offer and can only wait and watch.

On the one hand, these exchanges could represent a major opportunity for insurers, with their customer base rapidly expanding to include a large portion of those 30 million Americans currently without insurance. However, along with the tax penalties incentivizing Americans to purchase insurance come a slew of new regulations and taxes. And if too many young, healthy Americans decide they would still rather just pay the penalty than shop for insurance, it could result in a risk pool that disadvantages insurers.

However, it’s worth noting that, regardless of what happens in the exchanges, the individual market constitutes a relatively small portion of the health insurance market as a whole. About 85 percent of those people currently insured by private companies obtain their insurance through their employer.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Liked What You Read? Join Equities.com and Connect With Your Favorite Financial Experts FOR FREE! Members of Equities.com gain access to our leading financial news and content, active social investment community, proprietary research tools including the 2014 Small-Cap Stars, E.V.A. reports and more.

Results for HUM
2 Sep 14 05:35:28
HUMANA : Regulation FD Disclosure (form 8-K) http://t.co/KFiPhUc7FQ $HUM
BV Healthcare
2 Sep 14 05:34:08
$HUM Humana Inc files Form 8-K (Events or Changes Between Quarterly Reports) SEC Filing.. http://t.co/2SHd6s1jfE
2 Sep 14 03:02:55
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Trend $NBR $NFX $HP $TDC $PLL $CHK $HUM $AET $EQT $MRO $AMAT $DPS $OKE $NRG $ETR $NBL @ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
2 Sep 14 03:02:33
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Performance $NBR $SPLS $NFX $HP $TDC $PLL $AMGN $CHK $HUM $AET $EQT $MRO $AMAT $DPS more@ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
Market News Desk
2 Sep 14 00:25:27
$HUM: 3 Reasons Humana Inc. Stock Could Rise http://t.co/9l7HD9yENg http://t.co/LEaWz27VH7
1 Sep 14 23:45:08
Humana : Board Declares Quarterly Dividend http://t.co/VcRmb41wBZ $HUM
1 Sep 14 23:40:13
Humana : Health Information Trust Alliance Awards Certification to Availity http://t.co/4R0Lqkf2hk $HUM
Robinson Capital
1 Sep 14 20:42:28
#RobinsonHealthcareIndex $IYH 134.60 $IXJ 97.17 $IHE 137.62 $CI 94.60 $HUM 128.33 $PFE 29.39 $MRK 60.11 $AET 82.13 $AZN 72.59 $ABT 42.24
1 Sep 14 20:15:10
$IWEB closed up 100% today, on more than 290 MILLION shares traded! Huge News: http://t.co/ucQcnpafDY $UNH $HUM $CI
1 Sep 14 15:49:04
$IWEB closed up 100% today, on more than 290 MILLION shares traded! Huge News: http://t.co/ucQcnpafDY $UNH $HUM $CI
Biz Headlines
1 Sep 14 13:25:43
$HUM: Humana Inc (HUM) Plans Quarterly Dividend of $0.28 http://t.co/DIs5BamF0F http://t.co/wskBkV9waU
Market Headlines
1 Sep 14 12:25:23
$HUM: Humana: A Great Starter Stock For Insurance Investors (HUM) http://t.co/8WSaDBFgY3 http://t.co/tQRJLPJdlo
Action Jackson
1 Sep 14 12:11:35
@mcbridetd @fbonacci RT"What Happens When Health Plans Compete http://t.co/jYVcllUrI6" $UNH $WLP $AET $HUM $ci #ObamaCare #AffordableCareAct
Matthew Clyburn
1 Sep 14 10:10:55
RT @brucejapsen: Five Open Enrollment Tips To Cope With Obamacare, Employer Cost-Shifting http://t.co/5CGDJC4uGQ via @forbes #ACA $AET $CI …
1 Sep 14 08:56:38
Humana : The Nebraska Medical Center, Methodist Health System and Humana Announce Accountable Care Agreemen... http://t.co/ROKvx6nF0G $HUM
melanie faulkner
1 Sep 14 08:41:42
RT @brucejapsen: Five Open Enrollment Tips To Cope With Obamacare, Employer Cost-Shifting http://t.co/5CGDJC4uGQ via @forbes #ACA $AET $CI …
Dr. Maria Artunduaga
1 Sep 14 07:58:31
RT @brucejapsen: Five Open Enrollment Tips To Cope With Obamacare, Employer Cost-Shifting http://t.co/5CGDJC4uGQ via @forbes #ACA $AET $CI …
Bruce Japsen
1 Sep 14 07:52:30
Five Open Enrollment Tips To Cope With Obamacare, Employer Cost-Shifting http://t.co/5CGDJC4uGQ via @forbes #ACA $AET $CI $HUM $UNH
Jeffrey Blake
1 Sep 14 05:00:46
$HUM 5 Things Humana Inc. Management Wants You to Know http://t.co/ASdg9AuTtf
Harry Walkman
1 Sep 14 05:00:45
$HUM 3 Reasons Humana Inc. Stock Could Rise http://t.co/MExCHUFmMN
Stock News Guru
1 Sep 14 03:25:35
$HUM: Humana Forms ACO with Health Choice to Boost Patient Care http://t.co/bLPL2gxbZM http://t.co/voVpBLslUG
1 Sep 14 03:02:49
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Trend $NBR $NFX $HP $TDC $PLL $CHK $HUM $AET $EQT $MRO $AMAT $DPS $OKE $NRG $ETR $NBL @ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
1 Sep 14 03:02:32
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Performance $NBR $SPLS $NFX $HP $TDC $PLL $AMGN $CHK $HUM $AET $EQT $MRO $AMAT $DPS more@ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
31 Aug 14 16:38:05
Trending in Twitter Related to $HUM (HUMANA INC symbol HUM) on 08/31/2014 http://t.co/3RP1ygpdoM
Market Updater
31 Aug 14 14:25:21
$HUM: Humana Forms ACO with Health Choice to Boost Patient Care http://t.co/XQ1rZZuTMN http://t.co/p64alON4mv
Stock Market News
30 Aug 14 13:25:18
$HUM: Humana Rises on ACO Deal Announcement with 2 Entities http://t.co/uZrZEPcR8L http://t.co/PWap2fBKjC
30 Aug 14 12:32:23
$UNH - my fave HC Plans stock on sma200 pullback buys. Strong sector, as usual. $AET $WLP $CI $HNT $HUM others to consider #longterm
Wall Street News
30 Aug 14 11:25:27
$HUM: Humana Board Declares Payment of Quarterly Dividend to Stockholders http://t.co/jcD4UNX4zU http://t.co/EVQVNWdtbM
ARK Genome
30 Aug 14 10:54:28
Will $AAPL's #HealthKit platform, coming 9/9, carry #insurance benefits for users? Firm has talked with $HUM, $UNH http://t.co/ZDBJ4reUA2
Wall Street Monitor
30 Aug 14 06:25:18
$HUM: Humana Inc (HUM) Issues FY14 Earnings Guidance http://t.co/aa8PA7b36T http://t.co/IUPrvEbT5t
30 Aug 14 03:03:09
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Trend $NBR $NFX $HP $TDC $PLL $CHK $HUM $AET $EQT $MRO $AMAT $DPS $OKE $NRG $ETR $NBL @ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
30 Aug 14 03:02:49
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Performance $NBR $SPLS $NFX $HP $TDC $PLL $AMGN $CHK $HUM $AET $EQT $MRO $AMAT $DPS more@ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
Biz Headlines
29 Aug 14 18:25:21
$HUM: 5 Affordable Care Act Stock Winners to Buy Now http://t.co/76vE1asQNX http://t.co/HUZDiC0zAC
James Billingsley
29 Aug 14 18:07:43
$HUM nearing technical Highs Great company But I'm out!
BNK Invest
29 Aug 14 12:34:30
Video: Weekly Market Wrap: August 29, 2014 $RSH $AAPL $BAC $TWTR $HUM $BBY $CSCO $LOW $PPL $SYY #stocks http://t.co/r7O159fV8R
29 Aug 14 12:07:03
RSII shot up over 100% today! Major Update: http://t.co/GMnQioznZp $UNH $HUM $CI
Business Headlines
29 Aug 14 10:25:37
$HUM: Stocks Stay Mixed Ahead Of Fed Statement; Twitter Cools Off http://t.co/ed4UNp6s2Y http://t.co/tI7E3cY7fy
Market Int Center
29 Aug 14 09:49:52
Humana $HUM Trading Near $125.63 Support Level ( http://t.co/DVXHCUVGZg )
Al Sabogal
29 Aug 14 09:36:06
$HUM - up 10% in almost a straight line in under 3 weeks...mad I didn't buy it...set up well http://t.co/0fTDiguVnc
Daily Contracts
29 Aug 14 09:23:02
Real-Time feed of company contracts, original agreements and executive updates from Humana $HUM http://t.co/02EGkhlXZF
29 Aug 14 07:19:01
$HUM Sep Block Trade: 144 trade. ~$1.8 MM notional value.
James P Worthy
29 Aug 14 05:30:22
$HUM 5 Things Humana Inc. Management Wants You to Know http://t.co/neUStHwq8f
Financial Updates
29 Aug 14 05:25:19
$HUM: Humana: A Great Starter Stock For Insurance Investors (HUM) http://t.co/fzAib0NOz3 http://t.co/cjCSY0qcgC
Stock Market Monitor
29 Aug 14 04:25:20
$HUM: Hospice Oversight May Come From Rare Bipartisan Health Bill http://t.co/mjjRB9rmnI http://t.co/iqwigoADma
Stock Market Monitor
29 Aug 14 03:25:18
$HUM: Humana Forms ACO with Health Choice to Boost Patient Care http://t.co/OO63RWQv8G http://t.co/6JuohBBCrQ
29 Aug 14 03:02:54
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Trend $GME $TSCO $AMGN $TDC $BBY $HUM $AET $UNH $PLL $OKE $WLP $UNM $STX $AMAT $NTAP @ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
29 Aug 14 03:02:36
Weekly S&P500 #Stocks Performance $GMCR $ROST $GPS $GME $SPLS $TSCO $GILD $AMGN $CRM $TDC $VRTX $BBY $HUM more@ http://t.co/RPeaHBZz9y
28 Aug 14 16:24:59
$VIIC ran up 720% Today in an explosive move! Our new picks are coming soon: http://t.co/EdxLh9u5Nx $UNH $HUM $CI
Chris Wade
28 Aug 14 15:24:30
RT @brucejapsen: Another GOP Holdout State Expands Medicaid Under Obamacare http://t.co/O1U5BIXz8H via @forbes #ACA $UNH $HUM $AET $CNC $MOH
Bruce Japsen
28 Aug 14 15:06:10
Another GOP Holdout State Expands Medicaid Under Obamacare http://t.co/O1U5BIXz8H via @forbes #ACA $UNH $HUM $AET $CNC $MOH
By  +Follow September 19, 2013 9:13AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.