Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


Why Kareem Abdul-Jabbar is Right...and Wrong About Soccer in the US

By  +Follow July 2, 2014 3:49PM
Tickers Mentioned:

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar,big four of sports, world cup soccer, NBA, MLB, Stanley Cup, On June 30, former LA Lakers player Kareem Abdul-Jabbar published an extensively researched opinion piece on the future of Major League Soccer in America, and the outlook is not quite as bright as soccer fans had hoped.

Despite his undeniable bias toward basketball’s superiority, the numbers support what is obviously just a momentary spark in soccer interest. However, his analysis of why soccer can’t compete with the biggest American major leagues leaves much to be desired. The NFL, MLB, NBA and NHL are themselves offenders of what Abdul-Jabbar believes is keeping soccer from becoming the favorite American pastime: no game drama, low numbers on scoreboards, and muted player individualism. None of these have anything to do with American disinterest in soccer. The true reasons behind the MLS’s failure to launch is its lack of accessibility to the general public, as well as its heavy percentage of international players and absent representation in the American South.

Nationwide Broadcasting is on NFL’s Side

Football (in its American sense) is without a doubt the most watched sport in the United States. It airs on CBS (CBS), ESPN, Fox and NBC, and it is important to note that CBS, Fox and NBC are available without a cable subscription. This means that 75% of its broadcasting is available for free to the general public, making it the most accessible sport of all major leagues. As such it also earns the most television revenue, raking in $5 billion each season.

Major league baseball (MLB) follows in a not-so-close second, at $1.5 billion in TV revenues each season. The 70% difference is a product of decreased accessibility. MLB airs on Fox, TBS, ESPN and the MLB Network, and of those four, Fox is the only free national channel.

The NBA and NHL are also broadcast on only one national non-cable channel, and must compete with all other programming set to air throughout the day. This severely limits the number of games watched, and thus the sport’s popularity.

In 2013, out of 115.6 million household televisions, non-cable regular-season NFL broadcasting earned an average of 15.2 on the Nielsen rating scale. Comparatively, regular-season NBA was the second-highest viewed sport in the United States at just over 1.2. MLS scraped in at just under 0.3. The 2013 Nielsen ratings for the NBA and MLS represent viewership across all channels, and do not account for the change in viewership when cable television channels are discounted.

For broadcasters, fewer teams and fewer games means less television revenue. Not counting playoffs, college and major league football games are given similar weight in broadcasting. College baseball is less televised than major league, which explains the 70% difference between the NFL’s $5 billion and the MLB’s $1.5 billion revenues per season.

Small League with No Southern Representation

While the NFL is in a league of its own in terms of broadcasting and viewership, MLS is still at a disadvantage when compared with only the MLB, NHL and NBA. It has only 19 club teams, with empty membership in the South and across a large swath of the Midwest. Every other major league sport has at least 30 teams.

And although the Midwest has few teams in any of the major league sports, a Common Census study found that the Southern states represent a huge portion of sporting game viewership across all leagues. With no regional club soccer teams, the most intense sports fans located in the South do not tune in to MLS games, non-cable or otherwise. An ESPN SportsNation poll makes clear how important regional team support is to American audiences:



General public opinion supports Abdul-Jabbar’s claims that the MLS will never make it to NFL popularity. Further results from ESPN SportsNation polls are shown below:       

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Soccer, football   ESPN Sportsnation, Stanley Cup, NBA Finals, soccer, baseball, hockey


Where Is MLS Headed, and What Is Really Inhibiting Its Success?

But if action is what American viewers want, then why didn’t the fast-paced NHL’s Stanley Cup garner higher ratings than the NBA Finals? The word ‘boring’ is prevalent among articles recapping the 2014 NBA finals, and while it is true that basketball racks up points far faster than soccer, each goal made in a soccer game is nonetheless a strategic battle. The basketball court is smaller and the points are worth twice (often three) times as much as one goal in soccer, baseball or hockey.

Abdul-Jabbar’s call to the “American ethos” of individual feats relies more on abstract fluff than fact. He contends “soccer has its celebrated stars, from Pele to Beckham, but those skills seem muted on TV where we’re often looking at small figures on a large field and therefore these feats appear less impressive than they really are.” While soccer players do seem small and insignificant from a bird’s eye view of the field, so do football players lining up for the next play or baseball players in the outfield. It isn’t until the cameras focus in on a particular face that viewers connect with individual players. This is not particular to soccer.

While Abdul-Jabbar may be correct that soccer has only taken off in light of the World Cup and will remain benched in the major American sports leagues, aspects of his analysis fall short of explaining soccer’s failure to launch. The true reason behind low MLS popularity is general accessibility – with fewer teams to support in the most sports-heavy region of the United States, fewer Americans are willing to invest time and money into soccer.

Still, the league isn’t giving up the fight. Four new teams are slated for play in the national league, three of which will be based in the South. The Orlando City Soccer Club will begin play in 2015, while the Atlanta and Miami teams are expected to kick off in 2017.

These new teams are signing contracts with renowned international players, but while this may make matches more interesting, it threatens to again alienate viewers who are watching sporting events to support American players. For comparison, in 2012, 97.12% of NFL players were born in the United States while only 60.9% of MLS players were US-born. By continuing to define soccer as a global sport, the MLS risks negating its efforts to expand within US borders. And unfortunately, current polls and trends do not suggest national interest in MLS will be on par with the Big Four any time soon.


DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Signup for our daily newsletter and get our best articles emailed right to you!

Results for CBS
US Stock Ratings
1 Mar 15 09:52:02
Stifel upgrades $CBS from Hold to Buy, target price to $65 http://t.co/V3uLdX6vvc
1 Mar 15 09:35:21
Ogclip ©: Former President of SONY and $CBS speaks very http://t.co/SoKcddinbX
1 Mar 15 05:22:34
Morningstar Assigns BBB Credit Rating to CBS $CBS http://t.co/tuOL7PQxqD
Antonio Costa
1 Mar 15 03:01:54
Most recent insider trading - Sale : $ARMK $HON $GHC $GPRO $GHC $NFLX $RAX $GOOG $INTU $CBS $HD $EL $BK $ORLY $GS $LLL $CDNS $REGN $LNG
28 Feb 15 14:24:54
$CMLS unusual volume, acquisition from $CBS, earnings report... a story in the making.
28 Feb 15 12:05:17
#Virtual #reality slowly beginning take over of video game industry #VR $CBS, $FB http://t.co/oMHPsopoIx http://t.co/RXHAmzssQF
Cameron Wilmot
28 Feb 15 12:05:05
#Virtual #reality slowly beginning take over of video game industry #VR $CBS, $FB http://t.co/ZZq50eN21A http://t.co/ZNC4E0h2Hb
Market Parse
28 Feb 15 11:30:18
@BerryPinkStocks $CBS Your tweet has been featured on Market Parse, for iPhone. http://t.co/YHInvBCk4m
Franken Berry Stocks
28 Feb 15 09:20:23
Some people say the main stream media (MSM) is biased.. Lets have a look... CBS President David Rhodes is t $CBS http://t.co/sxQTwpEfAl
Market Parse
28 Feb 15 07:30:17
@ripuherSch $CBS Your tweet has been featured on Market Parse, for iPhone. http://t.co/YHInvBCk4m
28 Feb 15 03:16:03
$CBS: Investors Buy Shares of CBS on Weakness (CBS): http://t.co/x9RgrjaFrL
28 Feb 15 03:09:02
Investors Buy Shares of CBS on Weakness $CBS http://t.co/qHQbUstefe
27 Feb 15 21:59:37
For $29B which would you rather own, $NFLX, $VIAB, or $CBS? #DecisionsDecisions
27 Feb 15 19:21:04
$CBS: Investors Buy Shares of CBS on Weakness (CBS): http://t.co/b6Wl7emXM4
Sleek Money
27 Feb 15 19:20:32
Investors Buy Shares of CBS on Weakness $CBS http://t.co/LRSfXkgccu
Insider Alerts
27 Feb 15 18:13:04
NEW insider transaction on $CBS, CBS.A reported a moment ago: http://t.co/Ms6Z97ndYP
27 Feb 15 18:12:46
$CBS ALERT: New CBS Corporation SEC Filing From our Stock News Alerts App
Insider Filings
27 Feb 15 18:10:03
$CBS: MOONVES LESLIE sold a net $9,306,496 in CBS CORP. http://t.co/5GieYmA1MY #jivesearch
Stock Signaling
27 Feb 15 17:01:03
After Hours Volume Leaders: $KO $BAC $FB $AAPL $GE $C $WFC $MSFT $PBR $VRX $F $AIG $ISIS $CBS $JPM http://t.co/DEd0xkdNq4 #wallstreet #dow
27 Feb 15 13:42:16
$CBS CBS Corporation Weekly Summary Alert From our Stock News Alerts App
Issaquah Capital
27 Feb 15 13:17:38
Added a smidge of $STRZA to long book, nothing done on $LGF, $CBS or $TWTR short entry.. Back on Monday to troll this D.E. Shaw Algo tape...
Lauren Holmes
27 Feb 15 12:40:12
$CBS is a high quality tech $QQQ stock. We track winners that hedge funds are buying big. Check here http://t.co/huaLsH8iDZ
Market Int Center
27 Feb 15 12:38:24
Potential CBS $CBS Trade Targets 3.90% Return ( http://t.co/R4BsyGC28m )
Bursatil Biotech
27 Feb 15 12:18:46
OK,We're not having 1 of the greatest rounds but lets see. UPDATED Biotech $JUNO $ABBV $CBS $CVS $HSP $PFE $NVS $NMR http://t.co/Hi6FiTOwl8
27 Feb 15 11:19:36
After large gain on $EYES, $KBIO is next with $1 in net cash $BABA $CBS $VRX $SPG $NSC $ADS investors read http://t.co/t2YAvyw70P
Lauren Holmes
27 Feb 15 10:56:18
$CBS is a high quality tech $QQQ stock. We track winners that hedge funds are buying big. Check here http://t.co/huaLsH8iDZ
27 Feb 15 09:53:30
Weekly Media Notes: Mayweather-Pacquiao, M&A And More http://t.co/xuv3WiaVi9 by Trefis Team $CBS $TWX
Lauren Holmes
27 Feb 15 09:11:56
$CBS is a high quality tech $QQQ stock. We track winners that hedge funds are buying big. Check here http://t.co/huaLsH8iDZ
Sleek Money
27 Feb 15 08:20:41
CBS Receives Consensus Recommendation of “Buy” from Analysts $CBS http://t.co/GtSp9qJXEc
US Banking News
27 Feb 15 08:20:28
CBS Receives Consensus Recommendation of “Buy” from Analysts $CBS http://t.co/uhowddbJeA
Lauren Holmes
27 Feb 15 07:44:14
$CBS and $VIAB will be seriously affected by $NFLX going forward. Check our analysis here http://t.co/huaLsH8iDZ
Lauren Holmes
27 Feb 15 07:26:22
$CBS is a high quality tech $QQQ stock. We track winners that hedge funds are buying big. Check here http://t.co/huaLsH8iDZ
Breaking News Now
27 Feb 15 05:26:04
$CBS: CBS COO Sells $1666840.00 in Stock (CBS): http://t.co/OQx90peOLP
27 Feb 15 05:18:00
CBS COO Sells $1,666,840.00 in Stock $CBS http://t.co/tmfL7LbEwR
Breaking News
27 Feb 15 02:41:05
$CBS: Large Outflow of Money Witnessed in CBS Corporation: http://t.co/21X7HkNARO
Matt Soleyn
26 Feb 15 17:51:00
#HTGAWM 2-hour season finale is on ABC on 9:00 PM Eastern. 2nd hour runs against #VSSwimSpecial. $LB $CBS $DIS #TV
Matt Soleyn
26 Feb 15 17:08:33
Watching The #BigBangTheory on $CBS. #tv
Chris Kelly
26 Feb 15 16:33:17
Aereo parted out for peanuts in $2M bankruptcy auction http://t.co/eWz1naUmTc $TIVO, $RPXC, $DIS, $CBS, $FOXA, $CMCSA
Quantpost Service
26 Feb 15 16:15:07
$DIS $CBS News: "Aereo parted out for peanuts in $2M bankruptcy auction $TIVO …" http://t.co/xwiX9W9QZz Board view: https://t.co/arjccPCPz1
Consumer Stocks
26 Feb 15 16:15:06
Aereo parted out for peanuts in $2M bankruptcy auction http://t.co/9rEH0JsgeB $TIVO $RPXC $DIS $CBS
SA Breaking News
26 Feb 15 16:15:05
Aereo parted out for peanuts in $2M bankruptcy auction http://t.co/JsAewnMsQG $TIVO $RPXC $DIS $CBS
26 Feb 15 15:53:02
$CBS - TiVo, Others Buy Scraps of Aereo at Bankruptcy Auction http://t.co/BpsTX5yLmy
Market Parse
26 Feb 15 14:00:18
@MATTatACA Your tweet about $CBS had a sentiment of -1 and was featured on Market Parse. http://t.co/5WyUW5R8WJ
Market Parse
26 Feb 15 14:00:18
@MATTatACA $CBS Your tweet has been featured on Market Parse, for iPhone. http://t.co/YHInvBCk4m
26 Feb 15 12:45:07
Wall Street Senses Cumulus/CBS Radio Acquisition https://t.co/KL6Xks1rNu via @jdelcolliano #radio #wallstreet $CBS $CMLS
Lauren Holmes
26 Feb 15 11:59:47
$CBS is a high quality tech $QQQ stock. We track winners that hedge funds are buying big. Check here http://t.co/huaLsH8iDZ
26 Feb 15 11:30:11
Bought some weekly puts on $CBS to play a potential gap fill
26 Feb 15 11:07:02
$CBS: Victoria's Secret Touts Bikinis on TV in Bid for New Customers: http://t.co/j5F9wGR6cc
Matthew M. Polka
26 Feb 15 09:39:23
.@KatyontheHill @byersalex $VIA and $CBS know all about interent blocking...shameful they are not prohibited from anti-consumer actions.
Matthew M. Polka
26 Feb 15 09:37:46
.@byersalex Maybe the @FCC should ask $VIA and $CBS about #interent #blocking, where there is REAL evidence of violations.
By  +Follow July 2, 2014 3:49PM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.