Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?



Are Nielsen Ratings Still Relevant?

  +Follow October 17, 2013 9:23AM
Tickers Mentioned:

As football season hits its stride and the World Series premieres, media analysts continue to cite one metric when judging the success (or failure) of these media events: the Nielsen Ratings. Developed in the 1950 to measure viewership of television, Nielsen ratings rely on information provided by the several thousand “Nielsen families” that fill out “paper diaries” about their viewing habits. The operators of the Nielsen ratings system extrapolate from the information supplied by the Nielsen families to estimate the number of nationwide viewers of any given program.

If the system seems imprecise or outdated, it is. But it’s unlikely to change anytime soon.

How Imprecise are Nielsen Ratings?

Think of it this way. There are 25,000 Nielsen families out of 114.5 million television-owning households, or .02183 percent. Nielsen also fails to account people watching in a group setting, which has normally skewed the Nielsen ratings of “television events” like the Super Bowl.

Contrast the Nielsen ratings with the internal numbers the widly popular streaming service Netflix Inc. (NFLX) logs about its customer’s viewing habits.  Netflix knows exactly how many people are watching, to the person. To be sure, a little chicanery concerning people sharing Netflix accounts skews the numbers slightly. But the sample size is exponentially more accurate than, say, .02183 percent.

Nielsen has been attempting to rectify this streaming shortfall, and in February announced they’d begin incorporating streaming viewership into their counters in September. It still doesn’t account for everything, however.

The DVR Issue

Cultural events like Breaking Bad or sporting events, most viewers aren’t terribly concerned with watching a show the exact moment it was released. This has further affected Nielsen’s ability to accurately gauge viewership of particular shows, as many viewers choose to DVR shows and watch them at their own leisure – maybe even the next week, after the numbers are already logged (Nielsen only counts up to seven days after an initial airing.) Watching shows long after the fact is becoming increasingly popular, especially among viewers 18-49.

That age range, known colloquially as “the demo,” is the area most coveted by ad buyers. A show that logs a high percentage of viewers in the demo can charge ad buyers substantially more. And ad buyers have a vested interest in paying less. Hence, Nielsen stays outdated.

It’s All About the Demo

The reason Nielsen remains entrenched in its archaic model is pretty simple: a more accurate model would show how many young people are still watching shows. It’s not hard to see which shows are getting plenty of attention. Look at total show mentions on Twitter, for instance. That number, while not pegging exactly how many people watched a show on airing, does provide an exact, specific number of how many people are discussing a show.

Twitter mentions are chock full with shows popular with young people that have conspicuously low Nielsen ratings.  Take the Twitter mentions of the week of Oct 7-13:

1. The Walking Dead (AMC, Sun.)
Tweets: 1,172,000
Audience: 7,491,200

2. Glee (Fox, Thurs.)
Tweets: 822,100
Audience: 5,167,500

3. American Horror Story: Coven (FX, Wed.)
Tweets: 435,600
Audience: 4,623,800

4. Catfish: TV Show (MTV, Tue.)
Tweets: 743,600
Audience: 3,544,300

5. The X-Factor (Fox, Wed.)
Tweets: 422,900
Audience: 2,393,300

Of those five shows, only one, the Walking Dead, cracked the Top 20 in Nielsen ratings that week.

According to Pew Research Center, as of May 2013 over two-thirds of US Twitter users are in the demo. While the number of mentions and subsequent audience reach don’t peg exactly the number of views, they give us a pretty good idea of the shows the demo cares about. And it’s markedly different than Nielsen.

Why Ignore the Demo?

Failing to account for streaming, Netflix, and other non-traditional viewing habits does one thing: under-represent the shows young people actually watch and care about. Certain shows that are popular with the demo but don’t score good Nielsen numbers – Community, Mad Men, Parks and Recreation to name a few – can still be advertised on cheaply. Ad buyers can simply tout low Nielsen numbers, even when they know the viewership is higher.

Of course, as the sea change towards online continues unabated, it might just be a moot point. But while traditional media still has control, Nielsen with all its flaws will probably continue to reign. Just don’t think it means what young people are really watching is being accurately counted.


DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions. To read our full disclosure, please go to: http://www.equities.com/disclaimer

Signup for our daily newsletter and get our best articles emailed right to you!

Results for NFLX
3 Aug 15 15:34:46
DAL Delta Air Lines Inc. Current Price http://t.co/tfFLIBzobZ $DAL $NFLX $UA $AMBA #DAL #tradeideas #pennystocks
Investors Hangout
3 Aug 15 15:34:34
CELG Celgene Corp. Bid http://t.co/vbiGGQ2S3X $CELG $EA $LNKD $NFLX #CELG #share #stock
3 Aug 15 15:33:19
@Mazmasta you mind if I dm you for your thoughts on $nflx I've been following you on Twitter for a while now and I really value your opinion
Investors Hangout
3 Aug 15 15:32:14
AGN Allergan plc P/E Ratio http://t.co/kjnBPeNHUs $AGN $MGM $NFLX $TLT #AGN #stock #invest
Christopher Danvers
3 Aug 15 15:31:20
RT @Sentiquant: #toptickertweets $AAPL $TWTR $SPY $FB $FIT $LXRX $TSLA $GOOGL $PLUG $NFLX #sentiquant #FinTech 20150803 18:00:07:961
3 Aug 15 15:31:19
AIG American Intl Group, Inc. Current Price http://t.co/5yxYW88DTF $AIG $NFLX $KO $TZA #AIG #finance #stockmarket
3 Aug 15 15:30:51
$NFLX New SEC Document(s) for Netflix, Inc. From our Stock News Alerts App
3 Aug 15 15:30:02
$NFLX: New Insider Transaction on NFLX by Chief Content Officer: http://t.co/stxrZDctWn
3 Aug 15 15:29:45
$TWTR Twitter Inc http://t.co/UKZ3MRoLy9 #VoteJKT48ID #Greferendum $DYAX $HBAN $GT $DHI $CISCO $BK.B $AAPL $NFLX $WOOF $PZZA $SWKS $FB
Insider Alerts
3 Aug 15 15:29:11
NEW insider transaction on $NFLX reported a moment ago: http://t.co/3BprsWVWW7
3 Aug 15 15:28:35
$NFLX Amazon Beats Netflix For Its Most Important Content Deal Ever http://t.co/D8a0j10foO
The Cardiac Kid
3 Aug 15 15:28:04
$NFLX - Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4) http://t.co/PV7Arz77f4
Solo traders
3 Aug 15 15:28:04
$NFLX - Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4) http://t.co/oqg0lOV4cX
Hot Penny Stocks
3 Aug 15 15:28:03
$NFLX - Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4) http://t.co/bNK0RrzNJk
janet gale
3 Aug 15 15:28:02
$NFLX - Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4) http://t.co/sDW9V5IXlx
3 Aug 15 15:28:02
$NFLX - Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership (4) http://t.co/RZeEA8F3kc
Insider Filings
3 Aug 15 15:26:15
$NFLX: SARANDOS THEODORE A sold a net $13,394,585 in NETFLIX INC. http://t.co/hRCtQJL5HD
3 Aug 15 15:25:15
THEODORE SARANDOS A Chief Content Officer Sells $13,394,585 Worth of $NFLX Netflix, Inc. - #Form4 #InsiderTrading - http://t.co/XkHW8Hceyf
FinSentS SP500
3 Aug 15 15:21:44
$NFLX:US Netflix Stock Rating Lowered by Vetr Inc. (NFLX) #NETFLIX INC http://t.co/0xPlSLbUaa #SP500
3 Aug 15 15:20:55
$nflx on every pivot 112.9 to 112.1 move today, thrice you could have had rips. 500 stks u could hv made 2k!! http://t.co/H848KIBV9D
3 Aug 15 15:20:49
$TWTR Twitter Inc http://t.co/UKZ3MRoLy9 #KCA #VoteJKT48ID #Greferendum $DYAX $HBAN $GT $DHI $CISCO $BK.B $AAPL $NFLX $WOOF $PZZA $SWKS
Iconic Day Trading
3 Aug 15 15:15:22
@ejocam @pjraitt see Ec. I do call longs. Lol. Decent Monday. $BIDU both ways $NFLX among others. #payitforward #circle #teamwork
3 Aug 15 15:12:11
Elder Blue http://t.co/tretdB4yTl $XLI $ORCL $NFLX $RAD $HTZ $KGC $JNK $HYG $GPK $FITB $DDR $LVS $SPXS $IAG $IWF $EGO $ALU $TJX
Malibu Investment
3 Aug 15 15:10:15
$NFLX similar issue, no? https://t.co/ZKjD1373hq
3 Aug 15 15:02:21
Option volume leaders @ CBOE: $AAPL $MWE $TWTR $FB $RIG $BAC $DIS $WMB $NFLX $CHK $XOM @CBOE http://t.co/Y6Su5EPdiy
3 Aug 15 15:00:01
#toptickertweets $AAPL $TWTR $SPY $FB $FIT $LXRX $TSLA $GOOGL $PLUG $NFLX #sentiquant #FinTech 20150803 18:00:07:961
3 Aug 15 15:00:01
New 100K Challenge Starting Soon - http://t.co/upDpfLpMkH $AAPL $SPY $DIA $IWM $QQQ $USO $TSLA $GOOGL $NFLX $FB $GLD $GDX $YANG $BABA $YHOO
3 Aug 15 14:54:44
$NFLX Netflix http://t.co/UKZ3MRoLy9 #OXI #thisIsACoup #Griechenlands #Premier #Kompromiss #Greferendum #Grexit #GreeceCrisis.
3 Aug 15 14:54:20
$NFLX Netflix http://t.co/UKZ3MRoLy9 #OXI #thisIsACoup #Griechenlands #Premier #Kompromiss. #Greferendum #Grexit #GreeceCrisis.
3 Aug 15 14:54:04
$NFLX Netflix http://t.co/UKZ3MRoLy9 #OXI #thisIsACoup #Griechenlands #Premier #Kompromiss. #Greferendum #Grexit #GreeceCrisis
3 Aug 15 14:53:55
$NFLX Netflix http://t.co/UKZ3MRGmpH #OXI #thisIsACoup #Griechenlands #premier #Kompromiss. #Greferendum #Grexit #GreeceCrisis.
3 Aug 15 14:53:45
$NFLX Netflix http://t.co/UKZ3MRoLy9 #OXI #thisIsACoup #Griechenlands #premier #Kompromiss. #Greferendum #Grexit #GreeceCrisis
Nathan Lellouche
3 Aug 15 14:52:47
$NFLX I just can't wait to see the 13-Fs on 8/15
Best Trader
3 Aug 15 14:42:24
$TSLA [Tesla Motors] Sell Sell Sell $251.50 $FB $GOOG $AMZN $NFLX $AAPL $CSCO $BAC $INTC $FTR $LXRX @dastrader http://t.co/M4MJ9zmAeF
3 Aug 15 14:37:07
60% cash in @RobinhoodApp portfolio. Holding $DBVT $NFLX $CPXX $JBLU $WWAV $OXY $WFC $BRK.B $PYPL
3 Aug 15 14:36:45
Millionaire trading student http://t.co/MxPyS14Urw made millions learning to trade from http://t.co/BP4PFlvp00 $KITE $HLF $UWTI $NFLX $CAT
3 Aug 15 14:34:24
@modestproposal1 @altcap @Rich_Barton $nflx destroying old media but if u love a show and hate commercials there is this thing called DVR
3 Aug 15 14:31:13
AGIO Agios Pharmaceuticals, Inc. 52Wk High http://t.co/1Gr1SuP4hC $AGIO $XLY $NFLX $XLI #AGIO #nasdaq #stockmarket
3 Aug 15 14:25:28
Speak English or Die
3 Aug 15 14:17:02
3. They have more money than God. You're tellin me they shouldn't have any interest in $TWTR? Or $NFLX?
US Consumer News
3 Aug 15 14:16:26
Netflix initiated by Guggenheim at buy. http://t.co/a2KvgBRbaU $NFLX #NFLX
3 Aug 15 14:16:22
Netflix initiated by Guggenheim at buy. http://t.co/wHmm4A0QKM $NFLX #NFLX
3 Aug 15 14:15:04
NetFlix Inc. Initiated Coverage by Guggenheim Securities (Ranked 2nd) to Buy $NFLX #NFLX http://t.co/DNzi0fGTOS
3 Aug 15 14:05:04
$NFLX: When It Comes To Netflix Vs. Amazon, Bob Peck Says...: http://t.co/dtanJcJUNk
Farris BABA
3 Aug 15 13:52:09
$nflx price upgrade to 160
3 Aug 15 13:50:12
$FB Facebook http://t.co/UKZ3MRGmpH #Greferendum $DYAX $HBAN $GT $DHI $CISCO $BK.B $AAPL $NFLX $WOOF $PZZA $SWKS $FB $CTAS $OHRP
Trade Forex Signals
3 Aug 15 13:48:05
NFLX is meeting its support on RSI at 50 $NFLX http://t.co/tCwGErPdKc ~ via http://t.co/Kd2qwcsyit
3 Aug 15 13:46:12
$NFLX Netflix To See Even More Upside http://t.co/hwDncwjuHv
TV_Trading Ideas
3 Aug 15 13:44:01
NFLX is meeting its support on RSI at 50 $NFLX http://t.co/u07gZXPZ5V
IH News Desk
3 Aug 15 13:41:33
NFLX Netflix, Inc. Yield http://t.co/lw2Xd1OXdq $NFLX $SUNE $TBT $SUNE #NFLX #finance #stockmarket
  +Follow October 17, 2013 9:23AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

 Today's Must Reads

Beyond Twitter: 5 Small-Cap Tech Plays Nobody’s Talking About

Will the Fed Continue Its Track Record of Unprecedented Moves?

Facebook versus Google: Who Rules the Internet?

Are These the Worst Business Documentaries on Netflix?

Saving the

Small-Cap Market


Small-cap stocks offer investors many benefits, ranging from higher growth potential to overlooked value opportuni... in Equities.com's Hangs on LockerDome

About us

Equities.com is an advanced financial data portal and social network designed to connect self-directed investors with the world’s most innovative startup and small cap companies. Through our in-depth coverage of small cap markets, comprehensive research and stock valuation reports, state of the art issuer products, and world class events, Equities.com provides the social tools and insight that drive tomorrow’s investment relationships and opportunities.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.

Login or Register