logo
Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?

Register
    

Are Nielsen Ratings Still Relevant?

  +Follow October 17, 2013 9:23AM
Share:
Tickers Mentioned:

As football season hits its stride and the World Series premieres, media analysts continue to cite one metric when judging the success (or failure) of these media events: the Nielsen Ratings. Developed in the 1950 to measure viewership of television, Nielsen ratings rely on information provided by the several thousand “Nielsen families” that fill out “paper diaries” about their viewing habits. The operators of the Nielsen ratings system extrapolate from the information supplied by the Nielsen families to estimate the number of nationwide viewers of any given program.

If the system seems imprecise or outdated, it is. But it’s unlikely to change anytime soon.

How Imprecise are Nielsen Ratings?

Think of it this way. There are 25,000 Nielsen families out of 114.5 million television-owning households, or .02183 percent. Nielsen also fails to account people watching in a group setting, which has normally skewed the Nielsen ratings of “television events” like the Super Bowl.

Contrast the Nielsen ratings with the internal numbers the widly popular streaming service Netflix Inc. (NFLX) logs about its customer’s viewing habits.  Netflix knows exactly how many people are watching, to the person. To be sure, a little chicanery concerning people sharing Netflix accounts skews the numbers slightly. But the sample size is exponentially more accurate than, say, .02183 percent.

Nielsen has been attempting to rectify this streaming shortfall, and in February announced they’d begin incorporating streaming viewership into their counters in September. It still doesn’t account for everything, however.

The DVR Issue

Cultural events like Breaking Bad or sporting events, most viewers aren’t terribly concerned with watching a show the exact moment it was released. This has further affected Nielsen’s ability to accurately gauge viewership of particular shows, as many viewers choose to DVR shows and watch them at their own leisure – maybe even the next week, after the numbers are already logged (Nielsen only counts up to seven days after an initial airing.) Watching shows long after the fact is becoming increasingly popular, especially among viewers 18-49.

That age range, known colloquially as “the demo,” is the area most coveted by ad buyers. A show that logs a high percentage of viewers in the demo can charge ad buyers substantially more. And ad buyers have a vested interest in paying less. Hence, Nielsen stays outdated.

It’s All About the Demo

The reason Nielsen remains entrenched in its archaic model is pretty simple: a more accurate model would show how many young people are still watching shows. It’s not hard to see which shows are getting plenty of attention. Look at total show mentions on Twitter, for instance. That number, while not pegging exactly how many people watched a show on airing, does provide an exact, specific number of how many people are discussing a show.

Twitter mentions are chock full with shows popular with young people that have conspicuously low Nielsen ratings.  Take the Twitter mentions of the week of Oct 7-13:

1. The Walking Dead (AMC, Sun.)
Tweets: 1,172,000
Audience: 7,491,200

2. Glee (Fox, Thurs.)
Tweets: 822,100
Audience: 5,167,500

3. American Horror Story: Coven (FX, Wed.)
Tweets: 435,600
Audience: 4,623,800

4. Catfish: TV Show (MTV, Tue.)
Tweets: 743,600
Audience: 3,544,300

5. The X-Factor (Fox, Wed.)
Tweets: 422,900
Audience: 2,393,300

Of those five shows, only one, the Walking Dead, cracked the Top 20 in Nielsen ratings that week.

According to Pew Research Center, as of May 2013 over two-thirds of US Twitter users are in the demo. While the number of mentions and subsequent audience reach don’t peg exactly the number of views, they give us a pretty good idea of the shows the demo cares about. And it’s markedly different than Nielsen.

Why Ignore the Demo?

Failing to account for streaming, Netflix, and other non-traditional viewing habits does one thing: under-represent the shows young people actually watch and care about. Certain shows that are popular with the demo but don’t score good Nielsen numbers – Community, Mad Men, Parks and Recreation to name a few – can still be advertised on cheaply. Ad buyers can simply tout low Nielsen numbers, even when they know the viewership is higher.

Of course, as the sea change towards online continues unabated, it might just be a moot point. But while traditional media still has control, Nielsen with all its flaws will probably continue to reign. Just don’t think it means what young people are really watching is being accurately counted.

 

Results for NFLX
Bolt
21 Apr 14 05:15:26
@hulu should acquire @Aereotv building on existing partnership btw tv networks w/ unique offering unmatched by @netflix @amazon $NFLX @AMZN.
Streetwise and ROBI
21 Apr 14 05:14:39
RT @globeinvestor: Tech giants’ earnings to give glimpse of economy http://t.co/um6869tL9L $AMZN $NFLX $FB $AAPL $MSFT http://t.co/IcKua8cc…
Emmanuel Gromer
21 Apr 14 05:14:33
$NFLX Q1 2014 Netflix, Inc. Earnings Release - After Market Close http://t.co/2v7e8kTNk7
Financial Iceberg
21 Apr 14 05:12:39
Netflix Q1 Earnings Preview: Solid Growth In The Cards $NFLX http://t.co/sCRmO1e5Mr
StockViews
21 Apr 14 05:11:35
Morning Meeting: Eyes on Netflix $AMD $NFLX $HAL $KMB $ZION $PFE $ABX $NEM ... http://t.co/p1QTOJmuCy
REW Capital Advisors
21 Apr 14 05:06:59
REW Q1, putting on 29 new positions this AM @MillenniumHF #hedgefund $ICPT $NFLX $SRPT $ISIS $AEGR $SODA , etccc
EyeVest
21 Apr 14 05:05:44
Daily Market Action: Pro's start the week w/ a Bullish tone. Thurs. Buy Calls on $YELP $TSLA $NFLX.. http://t.co/0Pvq3fAKxx
Emmanuel Gromer
21 Apr 14 05:03:34
$NFLX How Netflix Inc. (NFLX) Stock Outshines These Four Stocks Select Comfort Corp ... http://t.co/S7lOzRvEVA
StockBreaker.net
21 Apr 14 05:02:38
Notable ER 4/21 $HAL $HAS $KMB $NFLX Get the full Earnings Calendar (FREE Reg):: http://t.co/0ghg43sr66
Alex
21 Apr 14 05:01:27
$VTPI morning every one $NFLX earnings today and $VTPI pump fun day ahead
Read_this_n0w
21 Apr 14 04:58:52
Nu Skin $NUS earnings now set for may 6th.. outlook guidance with reopend china sales to come $PLUG $FB $GOOG $WB $NFLX $SRPT
Financial Iceberg
21 Apr 14 04:55:43
Tech giants’ earning to give glimpse of economy $AMZN, $AAPL, $FB, $MSFT, $NFLX http://t.co/HgAG4LKZHr
Michael Corcoran
21 Apr 14 04:55:33
@jonsteinberg @SquawkCNBC you're a genius $AAPL should buy Dropbox. But what about $NFLX to really take over the living room?
MarketNews
21 Apr 14 04:55:15
$NFLX - Smith & Wesson, H&R Block, Netflix, Amazon and Comcast highlighted as ... -> http://t.co/XrC0ISQgcA #stock #stocks #stockaction
Informer
21 Apr 14 04:55:09
$NFLX: Q1 2014 Netflix, Inc. Earnings Release - After Market Close http://t.co/MQBHWXnMo1
SNN Team
21 Apr 14 04:53:16
$NFLX - Netflix - Is The Risk Understated? -> http://t.co/ANvexTIga2 #stock #stocks #stockaction
FinancePress
21 Apr 14 04:53:14
$NFLX How Netflix Inc. (NFLX) Stock Outshines These Four Stocks Select Comfort Corp ...: How Netflix Inc. (NF... http://t.co/RYaJpgmZiO
Kevin Davis
21 Apr 14 04:52:24
RT @ZonebourseNews: USA-Les valeurs à suivre à Wall Street (actualisé) http://t.co/UKxlHbPips $AMD $DIS $ABX $NEM $PFE $MSFT $CMCSA $NFLX $…
John J Gill
21 Apr 14 04:52:21
RT @SeekingAlpha: Netflix - Is The Risk Understated? http://t.co/5VLdXbOhsd $NFLX
Zonebourse News
21 Apr 14 04:50:08
USA-Les valeurs à suivre à Wall Street (actualisé) http://t.co/UKxlHbPips $AMD $DIS $ABX $NEM $PFE $MSFT $CMCSA $NFLX $KRFT $NEMUF
John Doran
21 Apr 14 04:49:55
$GOOG $NFLX U.S. Morning Call: Investors eye Netflix earnings http://t.co/lahWJnDDAe
Vanessa C.
21 Apr 14 04:49:41
RT @globeinvestor: Big earnings week ahead. Here's everything you need to know: http://t.co/nK9sG6lr3R $NFLX $RCI.B $AAPL $FB http://t.co/T…
Shawn McFarlane
21 Apr 14 04:49:02
RT @globeinvestor: Big earnings week ahead. Here's everything you need to know: http://t.co/nK9sG6lr3R $NFLX $RCI.B $AAPL $FB http://t.co/T…
Barbara Kollmeyer
21 Apr 14 04:45:55
.@slangwise $Nflx, U.K. housing and why Chevron deserves a look. http://t.co/OFgWAdkF0p http://t.co/PDwxl1eMUU
Emmanuel Gromer
21 Apr 14 04:41:34
$NFLX Smith & Wesson, H&R Block, Netflix, Amazon and Comcast highlighted as Zacks Bull and Bear of the Day http://t.co/Em04nN8ZQl
Waris Malaya
21 Apr 14 04:40:45
RT @TheDomino: Traders getting ready for another volatile trade on Netflix earnings...options mkt currently pricing in +/- 11% $NFLX move p…
Quantpost Service
21 Apr 14 04:40:19
$NFLX News Alert: http://t.co/KVUmYbCHTS Updated options view: https://t.co/N13ekOGUd1 All options views: https://t.co/hOBOoKUxHS
LM_Tentarelli
21 Apr 14 04:35:50
Will be covering $NFLX short on open based on Thursday close.
JoEllen Zacks
21 Apr 14 04:35:37
RT @ZacksResearch: Some major earnings announcements today include $KMB, $HAL, $NFLX, and more. http://t.co/9sS4COew7O http://t.co/xKmkaA4z…
MVora
21 Apr 14 04:34:24
GM tiny posse! $NFLX reports tonight. I prolly won't hold into eps- might regret it. Will sell near close
Patrick
21 Apr 14 04:33:23
.@bbcaaron Since $NFLX gain more subscribers then @HBO, then I wonder how long until HBO starts offering subscriptions through their site?
Dominic Chu
21 Apr 14 04:33:04
Traders getting ready for another volatile trade on Netflix earnings...options mkt currently pricing in +/- 11% $NFLX move post report $$
Johnny Trades
21 Apr 14 04:28:36
$NFLX Can see go another 30-40 and form a nice head & shoulder pattern on the weekly charts. But for now this stock is streaming higher
Bo Tian
21 Apr 14 04:27:48
RT @WrigleyTom: Some Key Earnings Reports | This Week #stocks #markets #trading $spy $NFLX $AAPL $FB $AMZN $BIDU $SBUX http://t.co/wYhKsF…
Dixon
21 Apr 14 04:25:24
RT @globeinvestor: Big earnings week ahead. Here's everything you need to know: http://t.co/nK9sG6lr3R $NFLX $RCI.B $AAPL $FB http://t.co/T…
Steph Seguin
21 Apr 14 04:22:27
RT @RaginCajun: Earnings On Deck | Momentum Trading with RaginCajun http://t.co/GCaWCDdii6 $NFLX $WYNN $AKS $MCD $VMW $AAPL $FB $FIO $ZNGA …
:: mark ::
21 Apr 14 04:17:16
RT @WrigleyTom: Some Key Earnings Reports | This Week #stocks #markets #trading $spy $NFLX $AAPL $FB $AMZN $BIDU $SBUX http://t.co/wYhKsF…
Shomik Ghosh
21 Apr 14 04:16:25
RT @WrigleyTom: Some Key Earnings Reports | This Week #stocks #markets #trading $spy $NFLX $AAPL $FB $AMZN $BIDU $SBUX http://t.co/wYhKsF…
Adam Smith
21 Apr 14 04:14:03
RT @WrigleyTom: Some Key Earnings Reports | This Week #stocks #markets #trading $spy $NFLX $AAPL $FB $AMZN $BIDU $SBUX http://t.co/wYhKsF…
Simon Thompson
21 Apr 14 04:12:58
RT @RiskReversal: The Week Ahead - $AAPL, $FB, $AMZN, $MSFT, $NFLX, $GILD, $SBUX, $V http://t.co/MoatKE3rT1 @EnisTaner
Zacks.com
21 Apr 14 04:10:47
Some major earnings announcements today include $KMB, $HAL, $NFLX, and more. http://t.co/9sS4COew7O http://t.co/xKmkaA4zL0
Financial Iceberg
21 Apr 14 04:10:45
Fibonacci Technical Levels $LNKD, $MSFT, $NFLX, $TSLA http://t.co/9oS0SQT17z
Tom Wrigley
21 Apr 14 04:10:08
Some Key Earnings Reports | This Week #stocks #markets #trading $spy $NFLX $AAPL $FB $AMZN $BIDU $SBUX http://t.co/wYhKsFpGKu
Aaron Sobeski
21 Apr 14 04:09:19
Earnings, earnings, #earnings. $HAS (Hasbro) beat the street in Q1, $KMB reports at 7:15 ET, $NFLX posts results later today.Stay with @BNN!
Dan Nathan
21 Apr 14 04:09:09
The Week Ahead - $AAPL, $FB, $AMZN, $MSFT, $NFLX, $GILD, $SBUX, $V http://t.co/MoatKE3rT1 @EnisTaner
Tim Weidman
21 Apr 14 04:06:22
RT @stockstobuy: Netflix $NFLX Earnings Preview - http://t.co/8QhXQWjOiQ
Zonebourse News
21 Apr 14 04:05:16
USA-Les valeurs à suivre à Wall Street http://t.co/E0KsVYJOxU $ABX $DIS $NEM $PFE $AMD $NFLX $MSFT $CMCSA $KRFT $NEMUF
Christopher Mantle
21 Apr 14 04:02:56
Action! $NFLX
				
				
  +Follow October 17, 2013 9:23AM
Share:

Comments

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.