Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?



As Sam Sees It: How Investors Can Get Something for Nothing

By  +Follow July 3, 2014 7:09AM
Tickers Mentioned:

passive investing, best investment strategies, low risk investment strategies, safe investment strategies

Each week, we tap the insight of Sam Stovall, Managing Director of US Equity Strategy for S&P Capital IQ, for his perspective on the current market.

For more from S&P Capital IQ, be sure to visit www.getmarketscope.com.

EQ: They say there’s no such thing as a free lunch, but diversification is as close as investors can get. What does that actually mean when they say that?

Stovall: In most cases, “no free lunch” means investors don’t get a higher return without paying for it in the form of higher risk. You don’t get something for nothing. If Sir Isaac Newton had a fourth law, it would be that for every level of return there would be an equal level of risk.

So actually, a diversified portfolio is the closest thing to providing you with a free lunch because if you put together asset classes that have low-to-negative correlation, then they might both take the stairs, but at different paces.

For instance, when you think of modern portfolio theory, it says that you want to maximize returns while minimizing risks. You can’t necessarily eliminate risks, but you can certainly minimize them. That’s why investors typically match up stocks with bonds because bonds usually have low correlation and even a negative correlation at times to stocks.

Sometimes, however, people don’t go far enough and they confuse quantity with correlation, thinking that having exposure to large-, mid-, and small-U.S. stocks, while also having developed international and emerging markets, as well as commodities and real estate, makes them well diversified. But, in fact, they are not because all of these asset classes are economically sensitive. They’re markets that are triggered by global economic declines, which tend to bring all of these asset classes lower.

In a nutshell, a free lunch comes from properly diversifying a portfolio where one asset class zigs when the other one zags.

EQ: In this week’s Sector Watch report, you discussed the “Free Lunch Portfolio,” which focuses on three sectors of the S&P 500: Technology, Energy and Consumer Staples. Why focus on these three?

Stovall: It was sort of a building process. I first was a little bit surprised to see that even when you include the dot-com bubble bursting in the early 2000s, Technology was still the best-performing sector within the S&P 500 since the sector indices were first introduced in 1990, producing a 9.6% compound rate of growth. However, investors paid for that return in the form of very high risk and volatility as defined by a standard deviation of annual returns.

So if Technology is the poster child of cyclicality, I wanted to identify the section that is regarded as the most defensive. That’s when Consumer Staples came up. For Energy, it tends to behave like a stray cat marching to its own beat, but at the same time, is also a late-cycle performer and an inflation edge.

So those were the three sectors that caught my attention. Then, when developing a strategy of one-third Energy, one-third Staples, and one-third Tech, and seeing the returns on an absolute basis as well as a risk-adjusted basis, I got my confirmation that these three were very good holdings within an overall sector portfolio.

EQ: What kind of performance did this strategy produce as compared to just investing in the S&P 500?

Stovall: My assumption was that by offsetting the volatility of Technology with the defensiveness of Consumer Staples, I would not get an absolute return that exceeded that of Technology, but I would’ve received a risk-adjusted return that was better in comparison, and hopefully better than that of the market as well.

As I mentioned, since 1990, the Technology sector has posted a compound annual growth rate of 9.6%, but its volatility was almost twice that of the S&P 500. The return of the S&P 500 was 7.1%, but surprisingly, the “Free Lunch Portfolio” posted a compound rate of growth of 9.8%—better than Tech—and its volatility was even less than that of the overall market.

So indeed we did get something for nothing. We got a substantially higher return with remarkably lower volatility by holding an early cycle in the form of Tech, a late cycle and inflation hedge in Energy, and a sector that holds up best in a declining market with Consumer Staples. We also ended up with a strategy that beat the best-performing sector of all.

EQ: As you stated, this is a good strategy for those that want a simple set-and-forget portfolio. Considering that investors are faced with so much more technology, information, opinions, and just all-around options now, do you see an increase in the tendency to overthink how they approach the market?

Stovall: Yes, I think investors do, mainly because I know I do. We have so much information available to us, so much historical data and so much academic research that we can apply to our portfolios that you end up being your portfolio’s worst enemy, and probably because you’re frozen by indecision.

There is so much data that could end up talking you out of making wise investment decisions. The reason why I say this is a set-it-and-forget-it type of portfolio is because you don’t need to know where we are in the economic cycle. If we’re in the early phase, then Tech will do well. If we’re in a late phase, then Energy will do well. If we’re in a contractionary phase, then Consumer Staples will do well. Over the long haul, stocks in general will do better than cash or bonds.

So my feeling is you just put it together and not worry about where we are in the cycle since most people don’t know anyways, and just let it ride. If you wanted to engage in rebalancing, which is recommended in order to get similar kinds of returns—but there’s no guarantee you will—you don’t have to sell anything. Just simply purchase more of those sectors that did not do as well, and that will allow you to rebalance without having to take any taxable consequences.

DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions. To read our full disclosure, please go to: http://www.equities.com/disclaimer

Signup for our daily newsletter and get our best articles emailed right to you!

Results for SPY
Bid Flounder
6 Jul 15 21:19:25
Two $GS interns hit some buy programs buttons while fucking in the janitor's closet near the close....$ES_F $SPY
6 Jul 15 21:14:45
Im 80% invested in $oil -oil may dip lower.Hitting $Uwti if it hits 45pb.Waiting 1 week to make next move.( $uco $uso $spy $gdx $xlf $aapl
Stock Market Outlook
6 Jul 15 21:14:14
Uncertainty Escalates After Greek Referendum http://t.co/X0ZZqCfxVk $TLT $GDX $SPY $XLB $FXI $HAO $RSX $EPI $GREK $EWZ $EWO $EEM $IEV
Seeking Alpha
6 Jul 15 21:14:13
Uncertainty Escalates After Greek Referendum http://t.co/8CfJfPBxmv $TLT $GDX $SPY $XLB $FXI $HAO $RSX $EPI $GREK $EWZ $EWO $EEM $IEV
6 Jul 15 21:13:44
We still maintain our $SPY 212s $IBB 380s short.
Michael Sanzo
6 Jul 15 21:11:41
Everyone on my stream is looking for another $SPY flush lower...probably means we do not get one.
John Randel
6 Jul 15 21:06:38
Kerry says Iran deal still faces difficult hurdles U.S. will walk away if Iran doesn’t compromise $SPY $USO http://t.co/kv5yYljB0U via @WSJ
Navi Avatar
6 Jul 15 21:06:06
$GMCR Just waiting on the end of deafening silence from mgmt regarding stock slide. Let em speak up...then it ll drop even harder $SPY
John Randel
6 Jul 15 21:03:52
Iran projects oil exports to almost double after sanctions lifted -- official $SPY http://t.co/BVK4M5fpG9 via @WSJ
Alpha Maven Alerts
6 Jul 15 21:00:40
$IBM active, relative volume: 9.34, 1H, 12:00 AM, #nyse $DJI $SPY
Alpha Maven Alerts
6 Jul 15 21:00:39
$GS active, relative volume: 11.92, 1H, 12:00 AM, #nyse $DJI $SPY
Alpha Maven Alerts
6 Jul 15 21:00:38
$FB active, relative volume: 4.47, 1H, 12:00 AM, #nasdaq $NDX $SPY
6 Jul 15 21:00:08
Video Trading for A Living (see my live $SPY trade step by step when u register) http://t.co/470yEBShL5
6 Jul 15 20:59:58
Cruise lines perking up with drop in oil-- $CCL $RCL vs. airlines not moving yet $DAL $LUV $AAL #stocks #trading $SPY http://t.co/tnkCmyHcEN
6 Jul 15 20:56:59
EU Commissioner Oettinger Opposes Greece remaining in the EMU $SPY $QQQ $IWM https://t.co/02sjGcnEur http://t.co/OzRuilMjIN
6 Jul 15 20:53:43
RT @seeitmarket: The Market Curse Of The 7th Year Of The Presidential Cycle http://t.co/tLLbZe2tTk by @RyanDetrick $SPY $VIX $STUDY
6 Jul 15 20:53:15
$SPX weekly squeeze is still on. chop becoming more volatile!? $SPY http://t.co/tGUQxDfmxC
ej meltzer
6 Jul 15 20:52:16
RT @chessNwine: I analyzed $FXI $USO $UWTI and much more in my video market recap from earlier: http://t.co/vKg0cPmxrL $SPY $STUDY
Arthur Trupp
6 Jul 15 20:46:00
The Ultimate $SPY Dip Buying Level http://t.co/qo1TsYY67E via @sjosephburns
Naomi Creighton
6 Jul 15 20:45:07
Web Stock buzz: $GREK $HUM $SPY $AET $RB (02:31 pm) #stocks #finance #stockmarket #StockPicks
6 Jul 15 20:42:19
$SPY smack down http://t.co/hW58CZ43a0
Woll Street
6 Jul 15 20:41:18
@CrackedMarket Problem is both options introduce more uncertainty to EURO future. Though I'm still expecting bounce but think $SPY gap fills
Guillermo Delgado
6 Jul 15 20:38:48
RT @WallStJesus: đź’¤ FUTURES BE4 BED ... $ES_F $SPY $VIX http://t.co/MKKSL061Db
Trade Forex Signals
6 Jul 15 20:38:20
I'm looking for where to put the stop order. $SPY http://t.co/D9oXDrGbAn ~ via http://t.co/Kd2qwcsyit
6 Jul 15 20:38:20
RT @StockTwits: For all of the news about Greece and China, the S&P 500 and Dow fell LESS THAN 0.5% -> http://t.co/msSIEalyKD $SPY $DIA
TV_Trading Ideas
6 Jul 15 20:37:44
I'm looking for where to put the stop order. $SPY http://t.co/brHAJHwRfy
6 Jul 15 20:34:49
RT @SJosephBurns: The Ultimate $SPY Dip Buying Level http://t.co/S8S1TNm4bU http://t.co/XsqhC6SPbX
6 Jul 15 20:34:07
Our ETF TRENDS are on FIRE! USOIL, $IBB, Shanghai, $SPY & much more! Ideas-> http://t.co/fXrbX0uJaI http://t.co/67aIPjLArh
Venky Srinivasan
6 Jul 15 20:33:16
"@seeitmarket: The Market Curse Of The 7th Year Of The Presidential Cycle http://t.co/k3T1HGqk47 by @RyanDetrick $SPY $VIX $STUDY"
Walter White
6 Jul 15 20:31:03
Shanghai making new lows here...they can't stop the selling. Even the Asian Cramer doesn't know what to think https://t.co/wlx56Z6pID $SPY
Scott Jensen
6 Jul 15 20:30:47
See ya'll at $Spy 198.xx, chart: @MktOutperform @WildcatTrader @allstarcharts @ReformedBroker @RyanDetrick @Sassy_SPY http://t.co/NLIdN9Uzh6
6 Jul 15 20:29:50
Minimum Spanning Trees Update: YTD Stock Market Correlations $SPY #datavisualization #wlst https://t.co/PhhCsBWQEy http://t.co/IEv8sCKDfM
6 Jul 15 20:29:47
New Minimum Spanning Trees for $SPX $NDX $SPY https://t.co/HfHj4tYU5T #DataScience #quant #trading #datavisualization http://t.co/8TffwOTQHI
Michael Sanzo
6 Jul 15 20:29:28
RT @jfahmy: If you missed my WEEKEND MARKET VIDEO, here's the link: http://t.co/E1n1xOr09K $SPY $QQQ $IWM $AAPL $TSLA
See It Market
6 Jul 15 20:27:36
The Market Curse Of The 7th Year Of The Presidential Cycle http://t.co/tLLbZe2tTk by @RyanDetrick $SPY $VIX $STUDY
6 Jul 15 20:27:34
RT @etfguide: How an $80k investment turned into $8.3 million via @IBKR http://t.co/veQbl62Gq1 $AAPL $AMGN $SPY
Woll Street
6 Jul 15 20:21:04
#GREECE future in #MERKEL hands tonight. No action may be construed as bad tomorrow. JMHO $SPY $QQQ $IWM
6 Jul 15 20:20:41
"@CNBCWorld: China firms rush to file trading halts as markets slump: http://t.co/HY5zHc3daO http://t.co/PCTTRQDyQP" $SPY $SPX $QQQ $IWM
Kevin Hincks
6 Jul 15 20:19:56
RT @_SeanDavid: Last Thurs I spoke on @Benzinga regarding short term market views, and some trades, listen here. http://t.co/MaJiDm54nX $sp…
6 Jul 15 20:17:48
Stock Market Futures Rally On Greece Varoufakis Resignation $SPY $QQQ $IWM https://t.co/ADZAM53Q7l http://t.co/vTnG7mqX6c
Jeff Hauschild
6 Jul 15 20:17:23
#oil #futures today looked like they believed a deal is near-assured in the #IranTalks . $oil $xom $xle $gld $spy $tlt #energy #Israel #fx
6 Jul 15 20:17:11
@_JamisonG_ the three year trend on copper is indicative of failed liquidity policies... But hey I was long $SPY so who cares
6 Jul 15 20:15:44
bosocial: $MCD sentiment rise to: 0.86, change: +0.87, sdr: 1.2, 1H, 11:00 PM, #nyse $DJI $SPY http://t.co/T4Ma4Q22Iw
6 Jul 15 20:15:37
Why we can finally buy the dip: http://t.co/wSe9jzcjUn $SPY $SPX $ES_F $QQQ $IWM
Jon Markman
6 Jul 15 20:11:13
RT @StockTwits: For all of the news about Greece and China, the S&P 500 and Dow fell LESS THAN 0.5% -> http://t.co/msSIEalyKD $SPY $DIA
6 Jul 15 20:10:09
$SPY $SPX $QQQ $IWM https://t.co/MygACjUCf9
6 Jul 15 20:08:57
$SPY creeping to $209 and $210.50 next week to restore market asymmetry. Squeeze is just a #bonus
Suzanne Carroll
6 Jul 15 20:08:37
RT @hanklute88: RT @GroomRosemary: RT @DeweyKnows: Another way to look at $SPY - still bearish pattern - head and shoulders top http://t.co…
Becky Hiu
6 Jul 15 20:08:31
Seems that the US markets are looking forward to this coming earnings season. Only the labor market seems decent, the rest are not very $SPY
6 Jul 15 20:07:45
Coming Energy ETF Price Changes, As Seen By Market-Makers http://t.co/bEWRZj2HTQ … $FCG $SPY $VDE $BNO $USL $XLE $IYE
By  +Follow July 3, 2014 7:09AM



blog comments powered by Disqus


 Today's Must Reads

Microsegmentation: The Future of Cybersecurity?

How this Playboy Playmate Became a Better Stock Trader Than You

Long Term Rates Are On The Up…What’s Next?

The Modern Web: So Many Ways to Invest in Wireless Mobile Stocks

It's Time for the Rest of the Country to Legalize Weed


Do you expect a 10% correction by the end of 2015? in Equities.com Polls on LockerDome

About us

Equities.com is an advanced financial data portal and social network designed to connect self-directed investors with the world’s most innovative startup and small cap companies. Through our in-depth coverage of small cap markets, comprehensive research and stock valuation reports, state of the art issuer products, and world class events, Equities.com provides the social tools and insight that drive tomorrow’s investment relationships and opportunities.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.

Login or Register