Sign in or Register

Already a member?

Sign in

Or sign in with your account on:

Not a member yet?


Why Invest in ETFs?

By  +Follow September 1, 2014 10:00AM
Tickers Mentioned:

Once one is familiar with what exactly an ETF really is, it’s time to start digging a little deeper. The question of “why” becomes more relevant. Because it’s your money that’s at stake, and before your retirement or child’s college education gets put on the line, it’s probably worth understanding why people may or may not agree with your strategy in regards to using ETFs vs. mutual funds.

After all, the stock market was around for decades before anyone made an instrument like this widely available, despite the fact that the core principles guiding their creation are really pretty simple. How, then, do we go from no ETFs to over a thousand in a matter of 25 years?

The question is actually an interesting one, and has been a source of considerable debate among stock-pickers and economists alike. Can you really beat the market? Or do we all just need to accept that it’s so wildly unpredictable it can’t be tamed?

Here’s a look at some of the core concepts that have been driving people to shift towards ETFs and away from mutual funds.

Passive vs. Active Management

At the core of ETFs is the idea that “passive management” of a fund has certain advantages that can’t be matched by “active management.” Fund managers are “active” because they carefully pick stocks, but ETFs are “passive” because they are designed to replicate a particular market, rather than outperform it.

It’s an idea that’s rooted to some degree in the efficient-market hypothesis that recently won Eugene Farma a Nobel Prize for economics. The Efficient-market hypothesis postulates that the market is “informationally efficient,” which is to say that all the information relevant to a stock’s price is processed almost instantaneously, making it impossible to beat the market without assuming risk.

The idea has fallen out of fashion to some degree after the bursting of the housing bubble, but it’s hardly irrelevant. Whether completely true or not, the core concept continues to have value. Basically, it’s next to impossible to consistently pick the right stocks over time.

Even the great Peter Lynch noted that a 60 percent success rate made one a success, and, to those believing in efficient-market hypothesis, legendary investors like Warren Buffet or Benjamin Graham who maintained success over lengthy periods of time are the exceptions that prove the rule.

Like most economic theories (or just theories in general), efficient-market hypothesis doesn’t have to be an either/or proposition, no matter how much some academics may insist on viewing it that way. Even if you believe that a smart manager can beat the market by assessing risk better than others, and that the market isn’t perfectly efficient, you can still most likely admit that the persistent failure of the majority of fund managers to beat the S&P 500 would indicate that there’s at least some validity to the theory.

Expense Ratios

Of course, one might wonder: why not go with active management? With passive management, you can guarantee that you won’t beat the market. At least active management gives you a shot, so why not?

The answer would be that active management comes at a price. The companies that manage mutual funds employ armies of analysts, do thousands of hours of research, and have top-tier stock pickers who don’t come cheap. All of that costs money, and to pay for it the companies charge an “expense ratio.”

An expense ratio is usually expressed as a percentage and it’s what these companies charge in exchange for managing the fund. It’s what percent of the total value of your investment the company takes annually. So, if you invest $10,000 in John Q. Mutual Fund which has an expense ratio of 1 percent, and said fund gains 10 percent over the course of the year, your investment is now worth $11,000, so the manager of the mutual fund takes $110, leaving you with $10,890.

ETF Expense Ratios

Now, ETFs also have expense ratios. Even passively-managed funds require some maintenance, namely crunching the numbers and determining how much of which stocks to buy to maintain a portfolio that will match the returns of its target index.

However, this is ultimately a lot easier than actually researching and picking stocks and, as such, expense ratios for ETFs are consistently much lower than for most mutual funds. Mutual funds often feature expense ratios of 1 to 3 percent, while ETFs typically fall between 0.1 and 1 percent (the SPDR S&P 500 Index ETF (SPY) has an expense ratio of just 0.09 percent).

This discount may seem fairly small, but for a careful investor, it makes ETFs an opportunity to potentially save thousands of dollars a year, depending on the size of one’s investment. And, given that many mutual funds fail to beat the return of their comparable index, the question becomes clear: why pay extra for active management when, more often than not, it doesn’t produce any discernable advantage in returns?

There are, of course, still plenty of reasons to invest in mutual funds. They offer a variety of advantages that, depending on one’s investment situation, could be important. But that doesn’t change the fact that ETFs are cheaper to own and get similar or better returns in the majority of cases.

An ETF: A Mutual Fund that Trades Like a Stock

Of course, anyone familiar with index funds is scratching their head right about now. Since the 1970s, there have been mutual funds that track a specific index much like ETFs do, making the difference between ETFs and mutual funds one that can't be immediately explained away with a simple breakdown of passive management.

As such, another key distinction for ETFs (and one that is arguably more relevant in understanding what they really are) is that they trade throughout the day just like a stock would. This differs from many mutual funds that set their Net Asset Value (NAV) each day and trade at that price over the course of the day.

This is because ETFs are managed in a way that allows for one to liquidate shares of the ETF in exchange for its underlying assets. This serves to ensure that the value of the ETF matches the value of the stocks it represents by creating an arbitrage opportunity any time the ETF trades at a value that’s different from its underlying assets.

Namely, if the price of a share of SPY gets to the point where it’s lower than the basket of 500 stocks that comprised it, one could buy it, cash it in for the stocks involved, and then sell them for a profit.

And, if investor enthusiasm pushes the price of SPY above its asset value, one can also purchase shares of the ETF in kind. So you would buy up the necessary stock components and trade them in to SPDR for shares in SPY, which you could then sell for a profit. On the whole, this ensures that ETFs will continue to trade at or extremely close to their asset value on a consistent basis.

And the flexibility ETFs offer over mutual funds, with traders able to buy and sell them at different prices throughout the day, is another advantage that makes them an attractive investment vehicle to many. So much so that there are now many ETFs that don’t track a specific index, and even some that are actively-managed. While this may run contrary to the passive management concept, it speaks to the dexterity of the structure as it outgrows its original purpose.

Ultimately, even when buying an index fund that benefits from passive management like most ETFs, the flexibility and market regulation of the fund's value against its underlying assets built into the ETF structure can provide certain advantages. What's more, an actively-managed ETF still offers these benefits when compared to actively-managed mutual funds.

Using ETFs to Create Your Ideal Portfolio

Whether you’re an adherent to the efficient-market hypothesis or utterly convinced that you can pick the right stocks to beat the best, it’s likely that there’s a place in your portfolio for ETFs. With over 1,200 to choose from, the options to make plays on the future of many different markets make ETFs an attractive tool for any investor.


DISCLOSURE: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors, and do not represent the views of equities.com. Readers should not consider statements made by the author as formal recommendations and should consult their financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Liked What You Read? Join Equities.com as a contributor and get eyeballs on your content FOR FREE!

Results for SPY
Robert Sullivan
24 Nov 14 12:35:09
$SPY Ponzi again, day 12456, Done as bear, fully embracing Central Banks and this Bubble! Long live the strong economy!
Jesusa Gonzalez
24 Nov 14 12:33:12
$TFSL Are you Bullish on these #stocks $DDR $OKE $SPY #economy http://t.co/61Fx03IJNl
24 Nov 14 12:31:45
@RampCapitalLLC whatever happens i guarantee generational buying opportunity for $SPY $SPX $ES_F #BULLISH
randall millard
24 Nov 14 12:31:23
RT @RedDogT3: I will be on Fix Biz for my weekly Monday hit on the technicals 3:03-3:07 $spy $spx
Wilburn Tribble
24 Nov 14 12:31:06
Stocks to Watch this week $JWN $SGEN $URI $SPY #NASDAQ http://t.co/AyyOgXGxv1
24 Nov 14 12:30:17
$SPY $IWM This market already feeling the effects of tyrptophan
Cornelius Luca
24 Nov 14 12:28:13
Eikon Weekly Charts Newsletter Trading Idea - $SPY $RRG: Energy Sector down, Health Care Sector up http://t.co/HkiiaVsfnv
24 Nov 14 12:27:45
$SPY respecting $207
Cornelius Luca
24 Nov 14 12:26:52
Eikon Weekly Charts Newsletter Trading Idea - Indexes - G-7: Long $SPY $SPX $nikkei S&P 500 / All G7 indexes http://t.co/1Frs87PBFX
Newton Research
24 Nov 14 12:26:24
RT @BrookeFinancial: $MNDO is up another +7% today, trading at 3.85, recommended on @NewtonResearch around 2.50. #trading $AAPL $TWTR $SPY …
p a
24 Nov 14 12:25:40
RT @seeitmarket: S&P 500 Technical Update: 2 Fibonacci Extension Targets http://t.co/ZlS4eDMTaz by @andrewnyquist | $SPY $SPX
24 Nov 14 12:25:03
been having some of my employees studying more when the #market is slow $SPY #trendfollowing $STUDY http://t.co/mM2pkcIe6E
Brooke Financial
24 Nov 14 12:25:00
$MNDO is up another +7% today, trading at 3.85, recommended on @NewtonResearch around 2.50. #trading $AAPL $TWTR $SPY http://t.co/LPxTcPPjf3
24 Nov 14 12:24:49
$SPY Does anyone think this will sell off 1st week of December for a 5-6% pull back ? Thank you.
24 Nov 14 12:23:18
$SPY http://t.co/LtmMs4e4yF
Options Trader
24 Nov 14 12:22:40
Bernie [14:46:01]: Bottom level cahnged to 207.02 .. at 2:46 we saw the hedge funds wanted $SPY littler lower
Forex Update
24 Nov 14 12:21:50
RT @tradingview: $GOOG - $GOOG Down 4.2% and $SPY Up 13.5% YTD - https://t.co/DpmavxYD6O
Kansas City Traders
24 Nov 14 12:18:55
$SPY close red ?
Max Ganik
24 Nov 14 12:16:21
This is what you call a boring day in the market. No setups at all $SPY $SPX $QQQ $VIX $VXX This is a result of the really low volatility.
24 Nov 14 12:16:03
BLOCK TRADE: $SPY 500,000 shares @ $207.08 [15:16:02]
24 Nov 14 12:15:42
Holiday Fever Takes Hold Of Stock Investors, But A Pullback Is Needed $SPY $VIX $BBH $XTN $SOXX $AMGN $CELG $UPS http://t.co/aP1BpbR7V1
24 Nov 14 12:15:41
have shorted $CPRT for #earnings last two quarters. Still don't like it here but will not be shorting it before earnings tonight. $SPY
24 Nov 14 12:15:01
$GOOG - $GOOG Down 4.2% and $SPY Up 13.5% YTD - https://t.co/DpmavxYD6O
Robert Sullivan
24 Nov 14 12:14:10
$SPY If this thing rallies at the close, I think I'm going to flip to bull, not worth fighting anymore
Joshua Hayes
24 Nov 14 12:14:09
"@KimbleCharting: New all-time highs hits 45. Matches number of new highs of last year! $SPX $SPY $IWM $QQQ http://t.co/xlwvOEUxwy" $STUDY
24 Nov 14 12:12:56
BLOCK TRADE: $SPY 501,242 shares @ $206.68 [15:12:55]
24 Nov 14 12:11:30
Unless you can scalp quick trades, environments like today are pretty worthless to trade imho. $ES $SPY
24 Nov 14 12:11:19
$SPY Economic Calendar http://t.co/1KkNTgdsaU
Serge Berger
24 Nov 14 12:11:18
$IWM about to catch up with the $SPY ? Relative chart for #perspective http://t.co/rRwA3N3roM
24 Nov 14 12:11:12
@WallStGhost @WallStreeTopGun won't close red! lol $SPY $SPX
24 Nov 14 12:10:11
tight range=increased risk. wide range=decreased risk. Haven't seen 1 good $spy setup. sometimes best to know when not to trade. #patience
Sean McLaughlin
24 Nov 14 12:10:01
Sarcasm Alert: "@toknees: Did you know: it is also possible to SELL stocks. $SPY $STUDY #factoftheday"
24 Nov 14 12:09:51
NEW POST: Big Blue Still Stuck in the Blue Grotto http://t.co/OMHAhqrrKf $DIA $IBM $QQQ $SPY $STUDY
Tony Parker
24 Nov 14 12:08:48
Did you know: it is also possible to SELL stocks. $SPY $STUDY #factoftheday
Cortney Crooks
24 Nov 14 12:08:42
$DDS Some Stocks to Watch $MCSA $LEG $SPY #Stock http://t.co/2CIUVEGzsp
Mr. Dolla Maker
24 Nov 14 12:07:56
$SPY Boring.
Alphonso Hyatt
24 Nov 14 12:07:36
Wow. Great #Stock #Research on $MPC $NFG $BEN $SPY Click http://t.co/87CHzsB57r
Alex L
24 Nov 14 12:02:54
RT @YahooFinance: Big Gaps To New Highs Bring Short-Term Pain, Long-Term Gain http://t.co/pa8ww4MwqA via @JLyonsFundMgmt $SPY http://t.co/8…
24 Nov 14 12:02:49
RT @BlockTradeAlert: BLOCK TRADE: $SPY 501,192 shares @ $206.68 [15:00:15]
Phillip Ressler
24 Nov 14 12:02:33
RT @YahooFinance: Big Gaps To New Highs Bring Short-Term Pain, Long-Term Gain http://t.co/pa8ww4MwqA via @JLyonsFundMgmt $SPY http://t.co/8…
Horacio Irving
24 Nov 14 12:01:54
Are you thinking of selling $IPG $CVX $DATA $SPY #overvalued http://t.co/ZccrQ9gPBk
Lynell Dew
24 Nov 14 12:00:54
$PL Are you considering selling $NLY $MKL $SPY #overvalued http://t.co/PDJIbqaZxy
24 Nov 14 12:00:42
RT @BlockTradeAlert: BLOCK TRADE: $SPY 501,192 shares @ $206.68 [15:00:15]
24 Nov 14 12:00:16
BLOCK TRADE: $SPY 501,192 shares @ $206.68 [15:00:15]
24 Nov 14 11:59:50
Algos never run out of money. $SPY
Scott Redler
24 Nov 14 11:59:17
I will be on Fix Biz for my weekly Monday hit on the technicals 3:03-3:07 $spy $spx
24 Nov 14 11:59:05
Remember everyone. Buy more calls because they always ramp into the close. Also, it Thanksgiving. $SPY
Yahoo Finance
24 Nov 14 11:58:32
Big Gaps To New Highs Bring Short-Term Pain, Long-Term Gain http://t.co/pa8ww4MwqA via @JLyonsFundMgmt $SPY http://t.co/84f1R65qiE
ETF Database
24 Nov 14 11:56:17
$XLE $XLU dragging on $SPY .. $XLY $XLF leading the charge in green // Risk is ON $SPHB > $SPY > $SPLV
24 Nov 14 11:55:42
By  +Follow September 1, 2014 10:00AM



blog comments powered by Disqus

About us

Equities.com is the most advanced interactive online social ecosystem for the financial industry, serving as a resource center and next-generation communication platform that connects self-directed investors with public issuers, market experts, and professional service providers and vendors. Registered members can leverage our exclusive proprietary research tools such as the Small-Cap Stars, which outperformed 90% of all small-cap mutual funds, and robust do-it-yourself E.V.A. research reports. The Equities.com Issuer Dashboard is the ideal tool to communicate and manage investor awareness campaigns to the investment community, as well as to access valuable resources to help your company grow.

Market Data powered by QuoteMedia.
Copyright © QuoteMedia. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of Use.